Canva

Roommate arrangements become complicated when essential medical needs collide with firm personal boundaries inside someone’s home.

This homeowner rents a room to a diabetic college friend who recently announced that a service dog would arrive the following week.

The dog could provide vital medical alerts, but this young man strongly dislikes dogs and refuses to live with one.

Let’s take a look at the full story.

AITA Refuse to live with a Service Dog

I (26M) own my own home. It’s five bedrooms and way more space than I need.

I came into the house due to a death in the family, and I’ve had it for about two years.

He describes the current living situation.

I use three bedrooms: my room, my office, and my video game room. The other two rooms I rent out.

One roommate, I don’t know very well and he keeps to himself. The other roommate is a friend from college.

The friend from college is a diabetic. He has a CGM, and that’s how he manages it.

I honestly don’t know much more about his condition and don’t pry as it’s not my business.

But soon it became his business.

He recently informed me that he is getting a service dog that alerts for his diabetes. He’s supposed to get the dog next week.

I do not want to live with a dog—I don’t like them.

I told him he can break his lease for a new place, but he can’t have the dog in my house.

Then things got tense between them.

Until this, it has been overall smooth sailing as roommates. He’s angry with me and supposedly looking into ways to make me accept the dog.

He had a good situation at my house. He’s told me I’m an AH for basically kicking him out because he is disabled.

AITA?

The balance between compassion and your own personal boundaries isn’t always easy to find.

What did Reddit think?

This commenter reminds everyone that this homeowner is not a typical landlord.

At the end of the day, service dogs are still dogs.

While it’s within his right to refuse the dog, it doesn’t make the situation any less awkward or stressful.

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a landlord who took action after a resident refused to respect an assigned parking spot.

It’s a tough situation, so maybe a compromise is in order.

Neither man’s position is malicious: one needs medical support, while the other never agreed to share his home with a dog.

Because service-animal housing rules can be complicated, they should verify their rights and obligations before treating anyone’s departure as settled.

One house has five bedrooms, two frustrated roommates, and absolutely no room for an easy answer.