Site icon TwistedSifter

He Mocked His Friend for Identifying as a Slytherin—Then Learned the Joke Cut Deeper Than He Ever Intended

Woman reading a Harry Potter book with a green, outdoorsy background

Pexels/Reddit

Some jokes can land much harder than intended.

The following story involves a young man who joked about his friend being a Slytherin after a night out.

She was tipsy when she told him her Hogwarts house, and his comment left her unusually quiet.

Later, he learned that the remark had made her cry, so he’s worried that it might have damaged their friendship.

Uh oh! Maybe it’s best not to joke around with drunken girls, huh? Read the full story below for all the details.

AITA for saying Slytherins are pick me’s?

I (19M) was in an Uber back to my college campus the last week of school with a bunch of girls after a date party.

One of the girls, who I was friends with and I knew had a crush on me, mentioned Harry Potter.

She was a little tipsy, as were all the girls.

And I was the only sober one. I had a final the next day.

This young man was misunderstood by one of the girls.

I went around guessing people’s houses after proudly declaring myself a Ravenclaw.

When I got to her, I guessed wrong, and she said she was a Slytherin, basically the evil house in the books.

I laughed and said that a lot of people say they are Slytherin because they want to be different.

What I meant, but didn’t say, was that Slytherins in the books are all rude and elitist.

She got quiet, but I thought it was because she was tired, and we got back to campus shortly after.

He learned that the girl cried because of his comment.

Fast forward to now, she has been really short with her responses to me over the summer.

I asked her roommate, who was in the Uber, what was up.

Apparently, me telling her that made her cry, and she still is mad at me over it.

Was what I said really that bad?

Honestly, it sounds like a harmless remark… yet apparently, the comment hit a sensitive spot with the girl.

OP probably did not mean to insult her.

But I’m pretty sure apologizing and clearing up that it wasn’t his intention to hurt her could make things better.

Whoa! Some people take Harry Potter too seriously. Let’s find out what others have to say.

This person calls out OP.

Here’s another honest opinion.

The whole thing was very dumb, says this one.

Another one chimes in.

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a woman who finally blew up after years of being treated as the second-best sibling.

Finally, here’s a valid point.

Sometimes, the sorting hat sorts out more drama than Hogwarts ever did.

Enjoyed this story?

Readers who liked this also read this story about an employee who got back at slacking coworkers with fresh-baked treats.
Read Story
Exit mobile version