One Couple Faces Harsh Judgment After Leaving Their Child With Family For An Anniversary Vacation, Even Though The Child Was Staying With Grandparents
Shutterstock
Parenting decisions can feel especially loaded when a baby has recently been sick.
With a long-planned anniversary trip coming up, one couple decides their six-month-old is safer staying home with trusted nurses in the family.
The real conflict comes later, when a longtime friend uses that choice and one pickup mix-up to question the mother’s entire relationship with her son.
See how that painful conversation played out.
AITA for not taking my 6 month old to NYC?!
Hi, my name is Lois. My husband Bryan and I adopted our son James through a private adoption.
He’s nine months old now, but at the time of this story, he was six months and had just come home from the ER after a couple of nights due to low oxygen levels (he’s fine now, just has minor non-life-threatening health issues).
Either option seems fine.
Before we knew we’d be adopting James, we had a trip to NYC booked for our anniversary.
When the time came, I was torn—do we take him or leave him with my mom and sister (both RNs who watch him often)?
Ultimately, we decided it was safer and more stable for James to stay with them, where he had doctors familiar with his history.
It broke my heart to leave him, but we felt it was best.
A simple miscommunication.
My best friend Harper, who watches James every other Friday (only twice a month), agreed to help on one of the days we were gone.
I was really grateful. Two weeks later was her regularly scheduled Friday.
She hadn’t watched James in a while because she’s been backing out a lot last-minute, so my brother-in-law has had to fill in.
On this Friday, I mistakenly thought James was with my brother-in-law and not Harper.
She realized her mistake.
After work, I stopped by the store when Harper called asking if I was late to pick up James.
I was mortified and apologized, saying I was 10 minutes away and had mixed up who had him.
She said nothing then, but I didn’t hear from her for weeks.
I finally texted asking if we were okay, and she asked me to call her.
Wow, this would be very upsetting.
When I did, she told me I was a bad mom, that I adopted James for the wrong reasons, and said it seemed like I just wanted an accessory, like a pet.
I was devastated.
We’ve been best friends for 20 years.
She explains why they adopted.
My husband and I tried to conceive for over five years before turning to adoption.
We chose private adoption specifically to avoid agencies that pressure birth moms. We personally knew James’s birth mom and offered her support if she wanted to raise him herself. It was a decision made with love and care.
I told Harper her words deeply hurt me and that leaving James behind on the trip and being late to pick him up once didn’t make me a bad mom.
But those were the two things she cited.
Does this friendship stand a chance of surviving?
It’s been weeks.
She hasn’t apologized, but two days ago she texted asking if I needed her to watch James next Friday.
I responded that I’d rather focus on repairing our friendship and that I didn’t want to strain things further by asking her to babysit.
I asked where we stood, but she’s since ghosted me.
She seems to be handling this very maturely.
I’ve always supported her through her journey as a young mom without judgment.
I’m trying to figure out if I’m in the wrong here, or if it’s time to walk away after 20 years. I’m open to honest feedback.
Never Miss a StorySign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
If her friend thought she was being a bad mom, she should have had a conversation about it instead of dropping some comments and then ghosting her.
Let’s see what the people in the comments on Reddit say about it.
This commenter makes an interesting point.
I agree with this commenter.
Yup, let her go.
Exactly, she should have brought her concerns up long ago.
If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a friend group that’s split when one roommate backs out of their dream apartment.
It doesn’t sound like it is too much.
She left her son with trusted family for a short trip, then accidentally arrived late for one pickup after mixing up who was watching him.
Her friend called her a bad mother and questioned why she adopted him at all, while most commenters felt those accusations were far out of proportion.
One missed pickup turned into a friendship crisis nobody saw coming.
Enjoyed this story?
Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
