She Agreed To Watch Their Cat Without Pay, Then Got Blamed For Not Leaving The House Immaculate
Shutterstock
Doing a huge favor for friends usually comes with gratitude, not an unexpected inspection after the work is finished.
One cat sitter uses vacation days and drives six hours to help, but when the owners expect a spotless house, would you apologize or question the deal?
That disagreement leaves one friendship unraveling over a few dishes, some laundry, and very different ideas about what free pet-sitting includes.
See why one week with a cat ended with far more cleanup than anyone expected.
AITA for not cleaning my friends’ house after pet-sitting their cat for a week (for free)?
A while ago, I helped out two close friends, Steven (a good friend and former coworker) and his girlfriend Clara.
We worked together for about four years until I moved away 8 months ago, but we stayed in touch and I visited a few times.
I also became good friends with Clara.
They live in a rented house.
A new pet can be pretty exciting.
Two months ago, they adopted a stray cat.
They were absolutely over the moon!
Since they’d never had a cat before and I’ve had cats all my life, they messaged me constantly with questions.
They had a one-week vacation booked before adopting the cat.
Clara asked if I could come stay in their home and take care of her.
She said it was a big ask, but I was the only person she trusted. I have a flexible work situation, and they’re good friends, so I agreed.
Wow, she really went above and beyond.
I used 5 vacation days, traveled 6 hours to their city, and stayed 7 days.
I took care of the cat, watered plants, and sent daily photo updates.
Their fridge was fully stocked, I didn’t spend anything. But the week was rough.
I had relationship problems, tend to overthink, and the cat went into heat and meowed nonstop (they said they’d fix her before, but it didn’t happen). With not much to do and the constant noise, I was really drained. Still, I got through it.
On day 6, I sent Steven a voice message saying I was happy to be heading home and explained how I’d clean before leaving, but some mess would remain.
He replied I shouldn’t worry and they’d handle it all.
How much of a mess did she leave?
I left the next day. Second 6 hour trip.
Two hours after I got home, Steven called.
Very polite, but clearly upset, he said they were shocked at how I left the place, and told me Clara could not stop crying.
I was stunned.
I told him I thought part of the “compensation” for my help was that I didn’t need to leave the place spotless.
He admitted he misunderstood my message and thought I planned to deep-clean.
We ended the call politely and chalked it up to miscommunication.
Here’s what I left:
- Empty bottles (refundable in my country) stacked on the table.
- Trash that could rot was taken out; cardboard and other dry trash were left in one spot.
- Used towels and bedsheets in a pile near the bed.
- Some rinsed dishes in the dishwasher, 3–4 items were rinsed but not loaded.
No danger in reach for the cat.
I’ve lived alone for 9 years and have always been considered tidy. But yes, I failed to consider their much higher cleaning standards.
I apologized to Steven the next day for seeing only through my own lens.
Wow, Clara sounds insane.
Clara, however, sent a very harsh message: she was deeply disappointed, called me ungrateful, ended the friendship, and said I shouldn’t even dare to justify my behavior or apologize for anything.
That message hit me hard.
I lashed out in return, called her ungrateful, crazy, emotionally unstable.
Childish, I know.
Now Clara and I are done. Things with Steven are strained.
Never Miss a StorySign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
The damage is done. But I still wonder:
AITA for not leaving the house spotless after cat-sitting for free?
No way, these ‘friends’ are unappreciative. It isn’t like the house was left a disaster, it was a very reasonable amount of cleaning left to do.
Let’s see what the people in the comments think about this story.
She went above and beyond and they still aren’t happy.
Yup, they should be thanking her, not yelling at her.
This commenter has a great idea.
The friends had unrealistic expectations.
If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a woman who finally blew up after years of being treated as the second-best sibling.
This commenter says the friends are ungrateful.
The sitter spent five vacation days, traveled twelve hours round-trip, and cared for the cat for free before leaving behind only minor cleanup.
Steven initially accepted the misunderstanding, but Clara responded harshly and ended the friendship over dishes, laundry, bottles, and dry trash.
Most Redditors thought expecting basic tidiness was fair, but treating free cat-sitting like complimentary housekeeping went way too far.
They got seven days of free pet care, then somehow decided the missing bonus package was maid service.
Enjoyed this story?
Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
