Parenting decisions made in the moment rarely satisfy everyone watching, and one mother is currently dealing with the fallout after a birthday party disagreement.

Her 7-year-old son repeatedly blew out his sister’s candles despite being asked politely to stop multiple times, including being asked directly how he’d feel if someone did the same thing at his own party.

Watching her daughter grow visibly upset on her special day, the mother made the call not to give her son a piece of cake.

That decision, meant as a natural consequence for ignoring repeated requests to stop blowing out the candles, has since sparked outrage among certain family members who apparently think they know better than the parent actually raising him.

Keep reading for the full story.

AITA for not letting my son have any birthday cake?

My son, 7, was at our daughter’s birthday party.

He kept blowing her candles despite us politely asking him not to numerous times, including a rhetorical question on whether he would like it if someone else did this on his birthday party.

It was starting to impact the mood of the party, so the parent took action against the misbehavior, which prompted criticism from the rest of the family.

I could see my daughter getting a tad distressed on her special day.

So after she cut the cake, we gave birthday cake to all the children except our son.

Now certain members of our family are ticked.

Don’t these family members understand what it’s like to be a parent?

Redditors are sure to get a kick out of this one.

This commenter thinks there was a better way to handle this situation.

This commenter thinks this parent did exactly what she needed to do.

This user hopes her son learns a valuable lesson from this.

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a mom who can’t figure out why her babysitter quit after what she thought was a routine question.

Her family should stop trying to get involved with things that don’t involve them.

Multiple polite requests (including a direct question meant to build empathy) all got ignored before any consequence was even introduced, which makes this about as reasonable a response as parenting gets.

Family members reacting with outrage aren’t defending fairness, they’re defending a kid’s right to disregard his parents entirely without any actual accountability.

It’s not their birthday, it’s not their child, and it’s certainly not their place to override a decision made by the parent who was actually managing the situation in real time.