Anyone who has worked retail knows that “get me a manager” is usually delivered with the confidence of someone who believes they’ve just activated the store’s highest level of authority. The manager will arrive, hear the terrible injustice that has occurred and presumably override every policy while the offending employee watches in shame.

Of course, that fantasy gets considerably harder to execute when the manager arrives and the customer suddenly stops talking.

One grocery store employee was enjoying a perfectly normal shift when an angry Instacart customer stormed inside looking for her curbside pickup. The store’s app stops notifying employees about pickups after 6 p.m., and since it was already around 8, nobody knew she was outside waiting.

Not ideal, certainly. But the employee quickly tracked down the woman’s order—which consisted of exactly one item—and handed it over.

That could have been the end of it.

Instead, the customer demanded a $4 refund, rejected the explanation that Instacart would need to handle it and insisted on speaking to a manager.

The manager came over.

And suddenly, the woman who had just delivered an entire verbal complaint apparently had nothing to say.

Karen goes nonverbal halfway through her rant

At my job we offer online grocery orders through Instacart. We shop the items, bag them up, and deliver them to the person curbside when they arrive. However, the Instacart app turns off at 6pm and customers can no longer place orders after this time.

It was around 8pm or so and I was ringing out a customer having a nice conversation when I see a lady storm in through the front doors. She beelines for my register and stands there waiting for me to acknowledge her even though I’m clearly helping another customer.

I ignore her because that’s rude and after a few seconds she goes “I’m here for a Instacart pickup. I didn’t realize you weren’t going to bring it to my car and I paid for that.”

Okay, relax.

I say “We usually do carry out Instacart orders, however it turns off at 6pm so I was unaware there was anyone here for pickup.”

I realize this is a bit of a flawed system on Instacart’s part, however I don’t work for them so I’m just using what information I have.

She goes “Okay?? Can you just get it? This is already taking more time than if I had just come inside and got it myself.” (lol, its been 1 minute but ok).

What’s the rush, lady?

I say no problem and run to the back to look for her order. Of course, nothing is where we usually keep the Instacart orders. I check the customer service desk and find her order of one singular item. The label has her name on it (it was actually Karen, btw). So I grab that and head back to the register and hand her her item.

“Well I was charged $4 for carry out so I want my money back.” “Unfortunately, all Instacart issues have to be dealt with through Instacart. “THERE’S NO WAY TO DO THAT. GET ME A MANAGER!”

So I call my manager who is very clearly busy doing something else but says she will be there in a minute. So Karen is on the side of my register tapping her foot, arms crossed, waiting.

Quite the impatient bugger.

Anew customer approaches to check out. She only has a few items so I ring her up and make some small talk trying to diffuse the tension. She’s pleasant and I’m getting the vibe that she can sense Karen’s energy and is understanding my pain as she kind of smirks at the lady.

My manager approaches Karen and says “Hi, I’m the manager how can I help you?” I’m still helping the other customer so I’m busy but I’m listening to see what Karen is going to say.

Y’all…. She says nothing.

Huh?

For a second I think that maybe Karen doesn’t realize she’s being spoken to so I turn and say to my manager “This is her” and gesture towards Karen.

My manager tries again and still Karen is avoiding eye contact, looking at the floor, arms crossed. I’m like wth? So I go to hand the receipt to this other lady and Karen starts wildly gesturing at me and pointing between me and my manager.

She makes the hand gesture for talking and points at me. I’m actually flabbergasted because is this real life? She’s too good to explain her story all over $4?

Wow.

I’m just looking at her because WTH I’m not going to be bossed around like that. Then when I think things can’t get any stranger the OTHER CUSTOMER GANGS UP ON ME.

She goes “are you not going to help her??? She CAN’T TALK”. I look at her confused because 1. I thought we were bonding over this Karen 2. SHE CAN TALK WE JUST HAD A WHOLE CONVERSATION.

So she just keeps repeating “are you going to help her???” And me and my manager say “Yes, we are just going to step over here.”

Wow x2.

Because other customers are approaching at this point and a different cashier has arrived to help out. Karen refuses to speak and instead pulls out her phone and starts wildly typing. She shows the message to my manager.

I try to read it but its incredibly jumbled and just says that she can’t talk, wants a refund. My manager tells her the same thing that we can’t offer refunds and she needs to contact Instacart.

Karen throws her hands up at us and storms out. We are left dumbfounded wondering wth we just witnessed.

Never Miss a Story

Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.

There are some crazy Karens the wild.

I’ve worked retail for many years and have had my share of Karen moments, but this one has left me scratching my head.

Was she trying to pull a power trip on me or my manager? Did her voice box run out of juice? Was she trying to garner sympathy from onlookers?

I’ll never know.

People were understandably baffled by the customer’s sudden refusal to speak, especially considering she’d had absolutely no difficulty expressing herself moments earlier. Whether it was an attempt at a power move, a way to force the employee to repeat the entire complaint for her or something else entirely, nobody involved seems to have gotten an explanation.

There is, of course, an important distinction between someone choosing not to speak and someone genuinely being unable to speak at a particular moment. There are conditions that can affect a person’s ability to communicate verbally, and strangers aren’t necessarily going to know someone’s medical history from a brief interaction. So the strangest part isn’t simply that she switched to typing on her phone.

It’s the timing—and the expectation that the cashier should somehow become her spokesperson.

She had already explained the problem clearly, demanded a manager and then, when that manager arrived, gestured for the employee to explain everything instead. The other customer jumping in with “she CAN’T TALK” only made the whole interaction more surreal, considering she’d apparently missed the rather important opening act where Karen did quite a lot of talking.

In the end, none of it changed the answer anyway. The manager gave her the exact same information: the store couldn’t refund an Instacart charge, and she’d need to address it through Instacart.

This person has some jokes.

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about an employee who got the perfect revenge after being told he can’t work from home.

This person has a somewhat unrealistic explanation.

And this person says it like it is.

All of that escalation over $4 ultimately accomplished nothing except delaying everyone involved and producing one of those retail stories that employees will probably still be telling years later.