January 28, 2026 at 5:49 pm

He Ordered The Pizza Of His Dreams, But What Showed Up Was A Nightmare

by Liz Wiest

large pizza with lots of toppings

Pexels/Reddit

Ordering delivery should be a special treat- and even though mistakes happen, it can be super disappointing when it’s not what you expected.

What would you do if your order got messed up on a massive scale? One guy recently fumed on Reddit about his most recent pizza fiasco. Here’s what went down.

Chicken Alfredo pizza with no chicken or alfredo

My pizza came from this new place.

It was advertised to have mushrooms, spinach, chicken, onions and alfredo.

Sounds delicious in theory.

But all I see are a few tomato slices, and sauce that tastes like straight up mayo.

30 bucks and inedible!

Seems like something went wrong there.

I am grabbing a quesadilla down the road.

Well, at least the story had a happy ending. Let’s see what the good people of Reddit had to chime in.

One person seemed to solve the issue immediately.
Screenshot 2026 01 06 at 11.28.58 AM He Ordered The Pizza Of His Dreams, But What Showed Up Was A Nightmare

Others empathized with the original poster.
Screenshot 2026 01 06 at 11.29.08 AM He Ordered The Pizza Of His Dreams, But What Showed Up Was A Nightmare

Some people theorized incorrectly what could have gone wrong.
Screenshot 2026 01 06 at 11.29.21 AM He Ordered The Pizza Of His Dreams, But What Showed Up Was A Nightmare

And some simply took the opportunity to troll.
Screenshot 2026 01 06 at 11.29.30 AM He Ordered The Pizza Of His Dreams, But What Showed Up Was A Nightmare

He got delivery, but he probably should have gone with DiGiorno.

If you liked that post, check out this post about a rude customer who got exactly what they wanted in their pizza.