Wedding roles can get complicated fast.

Saying no feels different when another bride later gets a yes.

So one woman declines a former roommate’s maid-of-honor request.

Then her best friend asks.

See why the first bride takes it personally.

AITA for refusing to be someone’s Maid of Honour?

So one of my defining characteristics is that I do too much. I can’t help it, it’s just who I am as a person.

I give 110% when I commit to something—and it often leaves me drained and depleted.

A compromise I’ve struck with myself is to limit situations where I’ll be required to do that, so when I do do it, it can be guilt-free.

So when her old friend came to her with a big request, she was frozen.

My friend asked me to be her maid of honour two months ago.

I was shocked by the request.

I expected maybe bridesmaid, not maid of honour, as we’re not that close anymore. We used to be in our 20s and even lived together for a bit, but we’ve drifted, and I never expected to be asked to be MOH.

She decided it was more than she could handle, so she tried to decline gracefully.

I said no. I don’t have the bandwidth to be her MOH with everything I have going on, and my doing-too-much personality means I’d run myself into the ground doing it.

I thanked her profusely for wanting me to play such a role but told her I couldn’t, for the reasons above.

She was upset, but said okay.

But then came another layer in all the drama.

This weekend, my best friend asked me to be her MOH, and I said yes.

I’m sure you see the problem.

Friend 1 found out via Instagram (not mine or the bride’s) that I said yes to Friend 2 but not her, and is apoplectic.

The fallout ripples throughout the friend group.

Mutual friends are judging. I’m being called all sorts of names.

I called Friend 1 to talk—she says she doesn’t want to unless I’ll reconsider her offer.

I said I won’t.

I don’t know how else I could have navigated it, to be honest.

She tried to avoid this, but it’s out of her control now.

I deliberately didn’t post on Insta to preserve her feelings and even asked my bestie not to—which she agreed—but it eventually got out.

I cannot do both and chose the one I can freely give my all to.

AITA?

Never Miss a Story

Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.

This whole situation was a ticking time bomb of drama just waiting to detonate.

What did Reddit think?

The upset friend may think she’s being wronged, but she really isn’t.

There’s something to be said for protecting your mental health.

It does look a little suspect from friend #1’s perspective.

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a sister who let her brother maintain a shared car for years, and doesn’t want to start doing it herself now that he has his own car.

It was objectively a hurtful thing to do, no matter what the reason behind it was.

She turned down one maid-of-honor role because she lacked the bandwidth, then accepted the same role for her best friend.

Most commenters felt that was completely fair, even if the first friend was understandably hurt by what the choice revealed about their relationship.

Apparently maid-of-honor invitations do not come with a first-come, first-served policy.