January 14, 2026 at 10:35 am

Mom Asked Relatives To Give Her Kids Fewer Christmas Gifts This Year, But Her Husband Wants Her To Go Further Because They’re Overwhelmed

by Benjamin Cottrell

teenage girl receiving a christmas gift

Pexels/Reddit

When it comes to kids, too much of a good thing can start to feel like a problem.

One mother tries to manage the flood of holiday gifts for her kids while her husband wants firmer rules, setting up a tug-of-war over Christmas cheer.

Keep reading for the full story!

AITAH for refusing to demand that my family NOT buy my kids Christmas presents?

I need some help here because I don’t know if I’m being unreasonable.

As I think a lot of parents would agree, the amount of stuff that comes with kids is overwhelming.

Gifts, however wonderful, do tend to pile up.

My husband and I have two kids under the age of 10, and with birthdays, Christmas, and other events and holidays, we’ve accumulated a lot of stuff.

I’ve done my best throughout the years to give things away, pack things away, or throw things out as the kids outgrow them.

Her husband loves spoiling the kids to make up for his childhood.

My husband grew up in a culture that didn’t celebrate Christmas and finds the amount of stuff the kids get to be too much. I do not disagree; both families love to spoil our kids.

Every year at Christmas and on birthdays, I try to give our families ideas for experiences or things that they actually need.

This mother has tried to tamp down the gift giving frenzy, but it hasn’t always worked.

I am explicit every year that we find the amount of stuff overwhelming and that what the kids could benefit from most is special time with them. I even put parameters like “please only one gift.”

My family, and my mom in particular, LOVES Christmas, and their love language is definitely gift-giving.

It’s starting to cause some serious tension with her husband.

Every year my husband and I get into a fight because I refuse to take the rules further.

He wants me to put my foot down and demand that they follow our rules for gift-giving. He doesn’t think I’m being stern enough and even went so far as to say that he’s made his mom cry so she would understand.

(She’s much worse than my family—gives them stuff every time she sees them.)

So now she’s wondering if she’s going about this all wrong.

I refuse to go beyond what I’ve already done and also refuse to tell people how to spend their money, especially if it makes them happy and makes my kids happy.

So AITA for refusing to demand that my family not buy my kids Christmas presents?

Someone has to set boundaries here.

What did Reddit have to say?

This commenter shares a more balanced perspective of gift giving.

Screenshot 2025 12 22 at 11.34.36 AM Mom Asked Relatives To Give Her Kids Fewer Christmas Gifts This Year, But Her Husband Wants Her To Go Further Because Theyre Overwhelmed

Sometimes less really is more.

Screenshot 2025 12 22 at 11.35.35 AM Mom Asked Relatives To Give Her Kids Fewer Christmas Gifts This Year, But Her Husband Wants Her To Go Further Because Theyre Overwhelmed

This user isn’t a fan of how the husband handled things.

Screenshot 2025 12 22 at 11.36.03 AM Mom Asked Relatives To Give Her Kids Fewer Christmas Gifts This Year, But Her Husband Wants Her To Go Further Because Theyre Overwhelmed

Before boundaries are set, this problem will continue to persist.

Screenshot 2025 12 22 at 11.36.35 AM Mom Asked Relatives To Give Her Kids Fewer Christmas Gifts This Year, But Her Husband Wants Her To Go Further Because Theyre Overwhelmed

If the worst problem your kids have is feeling too loved, then maybe that’s not the worst thing ever.

Gift giving isn’t an Olympic sport, but some people certainly act like it.

If you liked that post, check this one about a guy who got revenge on his condo by making his own Christmas light rules.