Apartment Resident Watched Two Elderly Neighbors Hijack The Building Council Vote, So He Filed A Lawsuit And Challenged Their Shameless Power Grab
by Benjamin Cottrell

Pexels/Reddit
Nothing turned a peaceful building into chaos faster than a couple people with control issues.
So when two elderly neighbors seized the building council like it was a game of chess and started bending rules, one resident decided enough was enough.
So what began as a quiet objection turned into a full-blown lawsuit.
Keep reading for the full story.
AITA for publicly shaming two elderly neighbors and filing a lawsuit against them?
So, I (M, 30s) live in a mid-sized apartment building with a pretty standard setup: there’s a building council that oversees maintenance, budget, admin stuff, etc.
One day, the status quo changed in the worst way.
Everything went relatively smooth until two elderly neighbors — let’s call them Mike and Mod (both in their 60s-70s) — decided to make the building their personal chessboard.
Mike and Mod got themselves voted onto the council this year, but not exactly by the book.
Their methods were anything but legitimate.
They took over the annual assembly as “president” and “secretary” of the session (despite not being neutral parties), changed the voting rules mid-meeting, and ignored every objection that didn’t suit them.
The official minutes that came out later?
These people were quite dishonest.
Full of omissions and lies — including a claim that the vote for the council (which they now sat on) was unanimous.
Spoiler: it wasn’t.
I was the only one actually voted in through real consensus.
Their tyranny has only continued from there.
Since then, they’ve overstepped their role over and over — publishing official documents before they were even registered with local authorities, acting on behalf of the building without authorization, and most recently trying to get me to sign off on a contract “as a council” without even involving the building’s administrator.
That’s illegal where we live.
Finally, the final straw came.
Earlier this year, Mike made a completely false claim that the community could be subject to asset seizures due to a pending labor lawsuit — again, not how the law works.
I’m fairly certain that was meant to scare everyone into letting them settle things without review or transparency.
I tried to handle things quietly. I’ve been patient. I’ve offered peaceful ways out.
But now?
This renter decided to take this to court.
I’ve filed a lawsuit to challenge the legitimacy of the assembly minutes and their actions.
I’m also preparing a full public report to the community, detailing everything — and yeah, it names names.
I’ve been told I’m being petty, or cruel — that they’re elderly and maybe they didn’t mean harm.
But he’s done giving them the benefit of the doubt.
But at some point, “not meaning harm” still leads to serious consequences.
They’ve lied, manipulated, and acted like they were above oversight.
The community deserves the full truth.
AITA for going full transparency mode and dragging them publicly (and legally) after trying to keep things civil for months?
It sounds like this renter was left practically no other choice.
What did Reddit think?
This commenter affirms this renter is right to look out for the rest of his community.

Many HOA communities have a bad rep — and for good reason.

Just because they’re elderly doesn’t mean they should get a free pass.

Transparency should come before ego every time.

These awful neighbors treated the council like a chessboard, but this resident finally flipped the table.
If you thought that was an interesting story, check this one out about a man who created a points system for his inheritance, and a family friend ends up getting almost all of it.
Categories: STORIES
Tags: · aita, bad neighbors, dishonest people, lawsuits, neighbors, picture, reddit, top
Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.



