Scrabble rewards the players who know the most words, except apparently in some households where it also punishes you for learning new ones mid-game.

A player challenged his son’s turn after catching what looked like two sketchy plays and ended up inadvertently proving that “Blasty” was a legitimate word in the process.

When his turn came around, he had the tiles, he had the spot, and he had a 40-point play sitting right there waiting for him.

His family shut it down immediately, arguing that he couldn’t use a word he’d just challenged, as if the dictionary ruling came with a cooldown period.

He pulled his letters and played something else, but he’s still not convinced he did anything wrong.

Keep reading for the full drama.

I challenged a word in Scrabble, then was shamed for playing that word myself after we all found out it the word was real.

More of an ethical situation than a game rule situation, I think.

Friendly game of Scrabble, all family, group of 4.

He describes where things started to go wrong.

My adult son was stretching words as he ran out of letters. He turned existing horizontal word “Blast” into “Blasty” and his actual word was vertical “Spidy” (clearly wrong).

But I challenged both, actually.

So his son adjusts his play, but that didn’t stop the drama from getting even worse.

With the challenge, “Blasty” turned out to be real. But “Spidy,” not real. He pulled “Spidy,” turning “Blasty” back into “Blast.”

Then it was my turn. I turned a (now new information) real word “Blast” into “Blasty” with a Y that I had, and vertically, “Jolly.” “Jolly” was my word. It would have been a 40 point play.

But his family wasn’t about to let that slide.

My family yelled at me and said I couldn’t play a word I just challenged. That we should “look up all the words before we play them if that is how we are playing.”

I pulled all my letters and played another word.

AITA?

Who knew a game of Scrabble could go so south?

What did Reddit make of this situation?

This user thinks the word was fair game.

It’s worth digging into the nuance of this situation.

This commenter shares their take.

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a teenager who wants to work, but his mom thinks working past 8pm is too late for high school.

It was perfectly within his rights to challenge the word.

He found out “Blasty” was real the same way everyone else at the table found out: together, out loud, during the game. Using that information on his next turn isn’t some unfair loophole. It’s just paying attention — and players who pay attention get rewarded.

The family argument that he should’ve known before challenging is totally backward, because the whole point of a challenge is to find out. He found out, then he played accordingly.

The 40 points would’ve been earned fair and square, and the decision to pull his tiles instead was a peace offering he didn’t owe anyone.

Family Scrabble is supposed to be fun, which is why the unwritten rules always cause more drama than the written ones.