Shutterstock

Milestones can clash in ways that make everyone feel like they are being asked to choose sides.

A woman already has birthday plans with friends who took time off before her closest friend invites her to a graduation ceremony on the same day.

Instead of accepting the conflict, her friend keeps pushing for the birthday celebration to move so the ceremony can come first.

See why one calendar collision starts to feel like a friendship test.

AITA for picking my birthday over my friend’s graduation ceremony?

I have known my friend since I was a high school freshman. She is a year older than me, and we have been friends even as we both entered university in the same program.

I still have a year left, but she is graduating in June. It falls on June 2, but that is my birthday.

My friend has an extra ticket, and she is asking that I go and watch her walk; however, saying no is causing some kind of roughness in our friendship.

Changing the birthday plans would be complicated.

I politely declined because my birthday is on the same day, and I wanted to go out after my shift to celebrate my birthday with two of my friends.

She told me that I should do my birthday celebration the day before or after so that I can show up.

But I told her that my other friends and myself need to call out of work and cannot just make spontaneous plans, and that my friends already booked that day off to celebrate with me (unfortunately booking off isn’t possible for me and I finish work around 4pm).

We also made these plans prior to her request for me to come to her ceremony. I do not want to be rude and cancel on them.

Her friend doesn’t want to take “no” for an answer.

I did tell my friend that I would be very happy to attend her graduation party that she is hosting, I have gifts, and that I’ll be watching her videos/seeing her photos.

She is upset because she said that birthdays are annually, but a university graduation ceremony is once in a lifetime.

She said that we can always push my birthday celebration to the weekend since neither of us work weekends, but I want to spend that weekend practising for my exam that I would have on Monday (June 9).

I told her that our other friends may be available, but she explicitly wants me because I am in the same program/I am her closest friend.

Her other friends thinks she should keep her birthday plans.

The more she speaks, the more guilty I feel.

My other friends (the two I invited) are saying I am not wrong for wanting my own day and that I do not have to go if I do not want to.  Her family is going, and that should be enough, and that her graduation party is better-suited for friends since I would be sitting bout 3-5hrs at a ceremony where I’ll only see my friend for about thirty seconds on the stage.

They also remind me that they specifically booked the day off for me, and that we had these plans prior to the ceremony request.

She’s not sure who to believe about what to do.

I do think they are right as well, but my friend’s unhappiness is eating at me.

AITA? She stopped responding to my texts but the last thing she said was ‘You are my closest friend and we have been so close for so long now, so picking other people over me hurts’.

I do not want to cancel but she is insisting I am in the wrong.

Graduation ceremonies are really boring. I think going to the graduation party should be good enough and she should keep her birthday plans.

Let’s see how Reddit reacted to this story.

She shouldn’t cancel her plans.

This person didn’t even want to go to their own graduation ceremony.

Why didn’t her friend invite her earlier?

This person agrees that graduation ceremonies are very boring.

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a mom who can’t figure out why her babysitter quit after what she thought was a routine question.

This person calls the friend selfish.

She wanted to keep plans that were made first, especially since her other friends had already rearranged work to celebrate with her.

Her friend saw graduation as the rarer milestone, but OP still offered to attend the party and celebrate in other ways.

Nothing tests a friendship quite like two special occasions fighting over the same square on the calendar.