His Unfair Terms On A Shared House Left His Girlfriend Carrying All The Risk, So She Backed Out Of The Purchase
by Benjamin Cottrell
Long-term relationships require compromise, but when finances get involved, even the closest couples can be shaken.
When this couple had differing ideas of fairness when it came to buying a new place, they were forced to rethink their plan and their relationship.
Read on for the full story.
AITA for not buying a house with my bf?
I (F38) have been in a relationship with my boyfriend (M47) for almost two years. Currently, we own one property each.
We’ve the opportunity to buy a house together (50/50) at a great price.
It seemed like a good deal so she agreed, despite her reservations.
I was hesitant because the credit of the house needed to be under my name and I would have to sell my property to pay my mortgage and then request a new one, but I agreed.
A few days later, he suggested that I put the money from the sale of my property towards the shared house.
I felt it was unfair, because he wasn’t putting extra money.
But she wasn’t too pleased with how her boyfriend was splitting up the responsibility.
He offered to put the same amount of money, with the condition of not selling his property.
He told me that he will get a loan to match my part.
FYI, the house will be only under my name due to his poor credit score, so I don’t know how he will get the loan.
She presses him further on the matter.
After asking him about why he wanted to keep his property, he mentioned that if we broke up, he will return to his property and I will keep the shared house.
I tried to explain him that if he leaves before we pay it, I won’t be able to afford paying and maintaining it on my own, so I will need to sell it and I might not have enough money to buy one for a while.
In her boyfriend’s eyes she’s getting a great deal, but she disagrees.
He thinks I would be a winning because I would end up with a house that is more expensive than the one I currently own.
I feel that it is unfair for both of us and suggested that we either sell both properties or none at all, and cancel the purchase.
So, I canceled the purchase.
Now they’re left at a standstill.
Now he is telling me that I am being unreasonable and that he doesn’t understand my logic.
AITA for not buying the house because I will need to sell my property and he won’t?
Both relationships and financial agreements need to be built on stable ground.
What did redditors have to say?
If his credit score is any indication, maybe he isn’t the best judge of financial risk.
This redditor thinks her decision is absolutely understandable.
Maybe this is a “right thing, wrong time” situation.
She wasn’t willing to trade her stability on a gamble like this one.
In the end, she stood firm in her decision, even if it meant standing alone.
If you thought that was an interesting story, check this one out about a man who created a points system for his inheritance, and a family friend ends up getting almost all of it.
Categories: STORIES
Tags: · aita, credit scores, home ownership, homeowner, loans, picture, reddit, relationships, selling a house, top, unequal partnership, unfair, unfair treatment

Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.