April 12, 2025 at 11:55 pm

She Got On The Dating Apps Using Older Pictures, And Now Her Matches Are Saying They Don’t Appreciate It

by Ben Auxier

Shutterstock/Reddit

Everyone has a type, it seems, and what that means can be varied…and messy.

Listen to this tale of tactical attraction from an anonymous Reddit user:

AITA for using chubbier pictures of myself on a dating website

I (31f) have struggled with my weight my whole life.

I’m thinner now but I yo-yo diet so my thinness will probably not last.

A lot of people can relate to that – weight is hard to keep off.

I didn’t want to attract a man who’ll leave me for gaining weight.

So I did the opposite of what most women do, as I choose unflattering pictures.

The pictures I posted are like 30 to 60 pounds heavier, often without makeup.

This guy (28m) messaged me and we messaged for a few days.

Then came the odd, first, digital encounter.

Before meeting this guy in a public place with a male friend a few feet away, I video chatted this man so I know he is who he claims to be and he can see I’m me.

When we met in-person however, he seemed less impressed.

And then a second date, despite some disappointment.

On the 2nd date he also looked down so I asked him what’s wrong.

He said I catfished him, and I said that is how I really use to look.

He said I don’t look like that now, and I reminded him we video chatted.

He said he thought that the I was using filters during the video chat, and what I look like in pictures was the real me.

And now they’re both in a weird spot.

He said he’ll date me anyway because looks aren’t the most important thing to him.

Which is both sweet and insulting. Did I catfish him?

What do the relationship experts of the internet make of this?

2025 03 26 18 44 04 She Got On The Dating Apps Using Older Pictures, And Now Her Matches Are Saying They Dont Appreciate It

A sort of backwards misrepresentation is still a misrepresentation.

2025 03 26 18 44 16 She Got On The Dating Apps Using Older Pictures, And Now Her Matches Are Saying They Dont Appreciate It

It’s, like, catfishing in the third degree.

2025 03 26 18 44 40 She Got On The Dating Apps Using Older Pictures, And Now Her Matches Are Saying They Dont Appreciate It

You gotta be you.

2025 03 26 18 44 53 She Got On The Dating Apps Using Older Pictures, And Now Her Matches Are Saying They Dont Appreciate It
As a person with some super outdated headshots, I can honestly relate.

If you thought that was an interesting story, check this one out about a man who created a points system for his inheritance, and a family friend ends up getting almost all of it.