June 20, 2025 at 7:15 am

Her Sister Has A History Of Name Theft, So They’re Keeping Their Baby’s Name A Secret

by Ben Auxier

cute baby boy looking at camera

Pixabay/Reddit

The weeks and months leading up to a birth are exciting, stressful, and full of meddling, usually.

But this situation is pretty unusual in that regard.

Baby names have caused so much family drama, I swear.

Keep reading to see what’s happening here.

AITA for not telling my sister the name chosen for my unborn son because she used her BBFs baby name for her daughter?

My sister and I are both pregnant.

This is her second child and my first.

We’re both having boys.

When my sister had her daughter three years ago her BFF was pregnant at the same time.

My sister complained for 8 months that they didn’t have any idea what to name my niece and then all of a sudden she had a name right before she gave birth.

After my niece was born and her name was announced, my sister and her BFF started fighting.

The BFF said that was the name she’d chosen for her baby girl and my sister used the same first and middle name for my niece and she couldn’t believe she’d do that.

My sister said it’s first come first serve and she needed a name badly.

That her BFF had time to find another name.

So we’re applying “calling shotgun” rules to…naming humans?

My sister is due before me, a few weeks before, and with that in mind I don’t want her to do the same thing to me.

And she has asked.

Nobody knows we’re having a boy except me and my husband and we plan to keep it that way.

But my sister has asked what our boy name is and as an afterthought she asked for our girl name too when she realized I knew what she was getting at.

I refused to tell her.

Then came the name blame game.

She tried to whine about name sharing being the fun part of pregnancy.

I made up a couple of names on the spot to tell her and she saw through it.

She told me to just tell her the name and I said no again.

And now it’s a fight.

She asked a few more times, she even asked in front of our family.

It was our brother who joked that nobody should tell the baby name thief the name they’ve chosen.

My sister got upset and asked if that’s why I wouldn’t tell her.

She told me I was holding something against her that she never did to me.

Mom asked why I couldn’t just share the name and everyone would know my husband and I chose it first if my sister used it but I still said no.

AITA?

Let’s see what the comments make of this:

2025 05 26 20 50 19 Her Sister  Has A History Of Name Theft, So Theyre Keeping Their Babys Name A Secret

How many bridges does she really want to burn?

2025 05 26 20 50 32 Her Sister  Has A History Of Name Theft, So Theyre Keeping Their Babys Name A Secret

Subterfuge is needed here…

2025 05 26 20 50 52 Her Sister  Has A History Of Name Theft, So Theyre Keeping Their Babys Name A Secret

You can know the name if you answer my riddles three…

2025 05 26 20 51 04 Her Sister  Has A History Of Name Theft, So Theyre Keeping Their Babys Name A Secret

As some of the comments pointed out, keeping the name to yourself before the baby is born is extremely common.

It cuts off endless unwanted opinions, and stops people from getting disappointed if you change your mind.

Also…prevents theft, I guess.

If you thought that was an interesting story, check out what happened when a family gave their in-laws a free place to stay in exchange for babysitting, but things changed when they don’t hold up their end of the bargain.