August 21, 2025 at 2:22 am

New Neighbors Asked For Access To Their Backyard Because Theirs Wasn’t Fenced In, But They Said No And Now The Neighbors Are Being Rude

by Ashley Ashbee

A Golden Retriever smiling

Pexels/Reddit

It’s unfortunate when you get off on the wrong foot with someone you have to see and deal with sometimes, but that’s what happened with these neighbors.

See why there is bad blood between them.

AITA for not letting my neighbors use my backyard?

My partner and I  just got new neighbors. They moved in about a month ago. We met them briefly. They are a couple around our age and a daughter who might be 4 or 5 and a dog.

We have our backyard fully fenced in with a privacy fence. Their yard doesn’t.

I was out front last weekend when the couple came up our driveway and started chatting.

They mentioned that they were on a waiting list to get their yard fenced in but were told it would be a few months.

Shockingly, they want a favor.

They said they would really like their daughter and dog to have a place to run around but didn’t feel comfortable with the lack of fence (our neighborhood backs up to a wooded area and a creek).

They asked if they could borrow our backyard for a few hours a day so they could let everyone run worry free. I  immediately didn’t like this, but I told them I would think about it.

I talked to my partner, and we both agreed this wasn’t a good idea. We have two dogs ourselves, and they can be a tad protective of their yard. One of them also doesn’t love kids and the other one can be a tad dog selective.

Because of this, we would have to coordinate when we could let our dogs out and that’s just not something we want to deal with. There are just too many things that could go wrong. Plus that good ole American worry that if someone got hurt we could get sued.

Immediately, no.

The guy stopped by again on Wednesday and asked if we had given it any thought. I told him we had discussed it, and unfortunately it just wasn’t going to work out with our dogs and their schedule so we wouldn’t be able to accommodate them.

He immediately got sour and said it was nice to know how neighborly we were. He left abruptly but I could hear him muttering under his breath.

He and his wife have made a big show of snuffing us the last couple of days. My partner said they will get over it, and while I’m not going to reconsider, I do feel kind of guilty.

AITA for not letting our new neighbors use our yard?

Here is what people are talking about.

Yep. You’ll survive the snub.

Screenshot 2025 07 28 at 1.43.17 AM New Neighbors Asked For Access To Their Backyard Because Theirs Wasnt Fenced In, But They Said No And Now The Neighbors Are Being Rude

It’s wild. I don’t get it.

Screenshot 2025 07 28 at 1.43.50 AM New Neighbors Asked For Access To Their Backyard Because Theirs Wasnt Fenced In, But They Said No And Now The Neighbors Are Being Rude

Squatters are hard to get rid of.

Screenshot 2025 07 28 at 1.53.22 AM New Neighbors Asked For Access To Their Backyard Because Theirs Wasnt Fenced In, But They Said No And Now The Neighbors Are Being Rude

I’m sure the kid is a nightmare.

Screenshot 2025 07 28 at 1.45.11 AM New Neighbors Asked For Access To Their Backyard Because Theirs Wasnt Fenced In, But They Said No And Now The Neighbors Are Being Rude

THIS.

Screenshot 2025 07 28 at 1.45.50 AM New Neighbors Asked For Access To Their Backyard Because Theirs Wasnt Fenced In, But They Said No And Now The Neighbors Are Being Rude

I wonder what they’ll pull next. I hope they don’t poison the dog.

If you liked that post, check out this post about a woman who tracked down a contractor who tried to vanish without a trace.

Ashley Ashbee | Contributing Writer, Workplace & Culture

Ashley Ashbee is a contributing writer for TwistedSifter specializing in workplace dynamics, employee advocacy, and professional culture. Drawing on her real-world experience as a software consultant, she brings a unique, insider perspective to navigating office conflicts, toxic management, and trending professional dilemmas.

Holding a degree in Professional Writing from York University, Ashley combines her formal editorial training with her corporate background to deliver highly engaging, empathetic narratives. She excels at breaking down complex workplace dramas and translating them into stories that truly empower and validate modern workers.

Based in St. Catharines, Ontario, Ashley balances her time between the tech and publishing worlds with her love for the outdoors. When she isn’t consulting or writing, she can usually be found exploring local walking trails or experimenting with new recipes in the kitchen.

Connect with Ashley on LinkedIn and Twitter/X.