September 7, 2025 at 3:15 am

His Mom And Stepdad Took In A Bunch Of New Children, So This Teenager Chose To Go Live With His Dad

by Matthew Gilligan

teenager wearing a backpack

Shutterstock/Reddit

Imagine going from having an older sister, to your sister dying, to having divorced parents and multiple step and half siblings. It’d be a lot to process, and eventually, there might be too many new siblings to handle.

A teenage boy asked the readers on Reddit if he’s wrong for bailing out on his mom to live with dad after his mother’s place got way too crowded.

Read his story below, and see if you think he did anything wrong.

AITA for deciding to live with my dad full time because I don’t want to help with a bunch of kids at my mom’s house?

“My parents got divorced when my older sister passed away 8 years ago.

I (16m) struggled with it because one day my sister was gone and then so was my family.

Mom moved out and she and my dad fought. Mom wanted me with her. Dad felt I should spend time with both.

When they went to court my parents were given the same custody time with me and I’ve always had a week with each of them at a time.

He’s been through a lot…

5 years ago my mom remarried.

Tom’s the guy she married and Tom had two kids under 4 when they met. Him and my mom had two more kids together.

It was pretty chaotic and my mom and Tom pushed for me to be a helper with the kids and to choose to be their big brother.

Mom told me to take care of them like my sister took care of me. And she was always correcting me for saying half sibling or step sibling.

We had lots of fights about it.

I love my mom a lot, but I think we had different ways of coping with my sister’s passing. She wanted to move forward with Tom and the kids being our family the same as dad and my sister were.

He’s also stuck in the middle.

She didn’t like that I didn’t call Tom dad. And she didn’t like when I’d go for dad’s parenting time. She tried to get sole custody a few times.

I couldn’t ever see my stepfamily the same. They could never take that same place for me. I was never going to call someone else dad either or stop being dad’s kids because she wanted me to pretend with Tom.

I think I never got beyond accepting that they were there and tolerating the fact that mom’s family had moved on and that I had half and step siblings. I never really bonded with them. But I was kind and I didn’t take my issues out on them.

Tom’s ex passed away in February and my mom and Tom decided to take in her other kids, who are similar ages to my half siblings. Because of all the changes it meant I was supposed to share with three other kids.

This kid is under a lot of pressure.

My mom wanted me to really step up and help and be a good older brother and role model. She said the new boy would need me the most and I’d need to take him under my wing.

My mom and Tom told me I’d need to help out with the kids more too. Like walk some to school, help with homework, walk them to after school clubs and stuff like that. I was also supposed to babysit because a babysitter would be out of their budget.

It was all way more than I wanted to do so I asked dad if I could live with him and he said yes.

My dad’s lawyer said it was fine because the court order already covered me getting to choose once I was 16 and how calls would be all that would be needed to not risk custody going to mom if she fought it through the courts.

This is causing big issues.

So I call my mom and accept calls from mom twice a week.

She’s always so angry when we talk. She told me she was disappointed in me repeatedly and wanted to have a good reason why I was refusing to spend any time at her house.

I told her I didn’t want to help with all those kids.

Mom corrected me and said my siblings.

And I told her no. Not my siblings. I told her we’d argued before about that and I didn’t want to.

His mom thinks he’s being selfish.

She told me we argue because I won’t let go and accept that my family has changed and she told me now I was being extra selfish and hurting the four siblings I always had and refusing to even try and be there for the three new ones.

She told me family comes together at times like these and I ran away. She told me if she could love them all and move on from my sister’s passing then so could I.

It ticked me off and I ended the call and I redirect any conversation now to talk about other stuff.

But my mom still makes it clear she doesn’t like that I went from living with dad two weeks a month to four weeks a month and she only gets calls and no visits and the kids will grow up hardly knowing me.

AITA?”

His mom moved on so quickly that it literally pushed him away. I don’t blame him for leaving.

Reddit users shared their thoughts.

This person chimed in.

Screenshot 2025 07 31 at 7.01.12 AM His Mom And Stepdad Took In A Bunch Of New Children, So This Teenager Chose To Go Live With His Dad

Another Reddit user said he’s NTA.

Screenshot 2025 07 31 at 7.01.18 AM His Mom And Stepdad Took In A Bunch Of New Children, So This Teenager Chose To Go Live With His Dad

This individual shared their thoughts.

Screenshot 2025 07 31 at 7.01.31 AM His Mom And Stepdad Took In A Bunch Of New Children, So This Teenager Chose To Go Live With His Dad

Another person spoke up.

Screenshot 2025 07 31 at 7.01.52 AM His Mom And Stepdad Took In A Bunch Of New Children, So This Teenager Chose To Go Live With His Dad

And this reader offered some advice.

Screenshot 2025 07 31 at 7.02.05 AM His Mom And Stepdad Took In A Bunch Of New Children, So This Teenager Chose To Go Live With His Dad

That house was getting WAY too crowded.

If you enjoyed that story, read this one about a mom who was forced to bring her three kids with her to apply for government benefits, but ended up getting the job of her dreams.