October 4, 2025 at 9:21 pm

Her Baby Daddy’s New Girlfriend Is Treating Her Like a Surrogate, So She’s Taking Them Both To Court

by Liz Wiest

pregnant woman lying on her wise

Pexels/Reddit

Pregnancy and welcoming a newborn into the world is a trial even the most traditional of circumstances.

The age old question of “what to expect when you’re expecting” remains unanswered, though certainly, it couldn’t possibly be what one woman talked about in this crazy Reddit story.

Here’s what went down.

AITA for calling out my kids’ future stepmom for treating me like a surrogate?

I [29F] dated a guy Joe (30M) for 3 months before he left me to go back to his ex Kim (30F).

Right after we broke up I found out I was pregnant and now I’m at 24 weeks.

I let him know and he was ecstatic.

Turns out his girlfriend had fertility issues and would likely never be able to get pregnant naturally and he has always wanted to be a father.

Little weird bringing her up but ok.

Getting back together was out of the question for both of us so he’s still with his girlfriend.

Joe was only allowed at the initial appointment because of COVID-19 and we found out I was having twins.

According to Joe when he told Kim she had a mental breakdown about her infertility, and wanted to talk to me.

That can’t be good.

I met them at their house and Kim stated that she wanted to be involved in my pregnancy because she would eventually be the children’s stepmother.

She started telling me that I needed to do a home birth, that I needed to formula feed so that they could have the babies half of the week, that she wanted one boy and one girl, and that she wanted the kid to call her Mama since they would be calling me Mommy.

More like Mama Dearest it sounds like.

I shut her down and said I would make the best choices for my children and my body and left.

Kim continued to be overbearing and texting me everyday about my eating habits, exercise habits, and bitching about how her job wouldn’t let her take maternity leave.

At the virtual genetics counseling appointment, she attended instead of Joe and took over the whole meeting trying to talk about her family history which wasn’t relevant.

Kim must have skipped Biology class quite a bit in school.

When it came time for my 20 week level 2 scan, they allowed me one guest and Joe suggested I take Kim instead of him, which I refused to do.

Joe did end up coming and he found out the gender because I wanted to keep it a surprise for me so we could throw a gender reveal party.

I put a pregnancy announcement on my social media and then she put up an announcement saying they were expecting twins “the non-traditional way” and how blessed she was.

That’s one way to put that…

I was irritated but I kept my mouth shut.

Then she threw a gender reveal party and posted it on social media.

I wasn’t even invited.

Kim has GOT to go.

She also announced that she’s having a baby shower.

I commented on her posts and told her to stop treating me like a surrogate, that the kids weren’t hers, and that Joe didn’t have any claim or custody of the kids until they are born.

Good for her!

I then called Joe and reiterated all of this and stated that I would not be seeing either of them until we went to family court and that my mother would be my birthing partner.

He and Kim and some of her friends and family are saying I’m TA and her mother even called and insisted I give her one of my babies like this is the Parent Trap?

So AITA?

Sounds like these people have watched too many movies, or potentially even hatched this scheme on purpose.

Let’s see what Reddit had to say.

All were concerned.
Screenshot 2025 08 27 at 2.29.16 PM Her Baby Daddys New Girlfriend Is Treating Her Like a Surrogate, So Shes Taking Them Both To Court

A few jumped straight to advice.
Screenshot 2025 08 27 at 2.28.42 PM Her Baby Daddys New Girlfriend Is Treating Her Like a Surrogate, So Shes Taking Them Both To Court

Some offered tidbits of information.
Screenshot 2025 08 27 at 2.28.27 PM Her Baby Daddys New Girlfriend Is Treating Her Like a Surrogate, So Shes Taking Them Both To Court

One emphasized the danger of the situation.
Screenshot 2025 08 27 at 2.32.10 PM Her Baby Daddys New Girlfriend Is Treating Her Like a Surrogate, So Shes Taking Them Both To Court

And blamed Joe specifically.
Screenshot 2025 08 27 at 2.28.59 PM Her Baby Daddys New Girlfriend Is Treating Her Like a Surrogate, So Shes Taking Them Both To Court

This is about to be one, big, unhappy family.

If you thought that was an interesting story, check this one out about a man who created a points system for his inheritance, and a family friend ends up getting almost all of it.