Shutterstock

When you are the primary caregiver for someone with dementia, it is almost impossible to keep on schedule because you never know what you are going to have to do.

What would you do if your sister-in-law was angry at you for being late to her daughter’s kindergarten graduation, even though you explained that it was because your mother was having a rough morning.

That is what happened to the guy in this story, so he told off his sister-in-law and called her selfish (among other things). Now she is telling him that he isn’t welcome at the house or to see his niece or nephew.

While I think the sister-in-law is very selfish, he should have held his tongue to keep the peace. Read through the full story and see if you agree.

AITA for calling my SIL selfish in front of her parents, my brother, and their children?

My nieces kindergarten graduation was last week, I was a little late because our mom was having a moment, she has dementia.

This family is a lot of work.

I am her primary, and to be frank, only caregiver. My brother sometimes will help with occasional bill or doctor’s appointment.

His wife is bipolar, so he already has his hands full, my nephew is lowish function on the spectrum he is 16 but at a 6th or so grade level. So he does have his hands tied.

Kids don’t always understand that sometimes life gets in the way.

My SIL was upset I was late because my niece was really looking forward to showing me her dance, but I missed it and it threw her entire graduation off.

She blamed me because I promised, I told her that mom was having an off morning and took me a little longer to get her ready and I still had to bring her to adult day.

Oh, it is the sister-in-law who is throwing a fit.

She was not having it, I tried to change the subject but she just kept hammering on.

She was saying things like if I cannot handle mom, I should place her or hire help.

Maybe he should have held his tongue a little better.

At this point I lost it and told her I would love to hire help, but mom went on early retirement to care for her grandson and provide free child labor for nearly 12 hours a day for over 10 years. Mom’s dementia started around covid.

Also, told her maybe my brother could help more if she did not lose her job for abusing FMLA every other year and eventually got caught / called out.

I mean, this is hurtful, but I don’t know that it isn’t true.

Now she does not work even though she is capable of working. I told her he legit feels like he has to walk on eggshells around her because her lows and highs are just not manageable.

I just summed it up and called her a selfish little drama queen that wants the world to run around her.

Sometimes it is best to just keep the peace.

She even doubled down and said if that is how I feel then I will never be able to see my niece or nephew.

My brother did not think what I said was wrong per-se but felt I should not have said anything cause now my niece, nephew, and my brother will not be able to see me without a fight, and I do feel bad for that.​

AITA?

While I can certainly see why he was frustrated, it is often best to just hold your tongue to keep the peace. Then again, maybe the sister-in-law needed to hear it.

Let’s keep reading and see what the people in the comments think about it.

Never Miss a Story

Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.

How he reacted is completely understandable.

This is all too true.

It won’t make much of a difference, sadly.

I doubt it will fix anything.

This person thinks his brother might be in an abusive relationship.

She definitely needed to hear this, though I doubt it will do any good. People like this almost never change or take accountability for their bad behavior.

He may have burned this bridge, which will make it harder to see his brother, niece, and nephew. Hopefully the family can get through it.

Add TwistedSifter to your Google News Add us as a preferred source on Google

Author

Michael Levanduski