December 16, 2025 at 1:35 pm

Boyfriend Always Received Christmas Gifts For His Girlfriend’s Family, But Refused To Buy Them Any Because He Doesn’t Celebrate The Holiday

by Benjamin Cottrell

man looking sad at christmas

Pexels/Reddit

Navigating cultural differences in a relationship isn’t easy, but good couples find a balance.

One boyfriend was put to the test when his girlfriend suggested he buy gifts for her family this year, even though he didn’t celebrate Christmas.

So when he refused, he was left to reckon with his own selfish instincts.

Keep reading for the full story.

AITA for refusing to buy my gf’s family Christmas presents because I don’t celebrate the holiday?

My GF and I have been together for 3 years and we usually spend the Christmas break apart.

The two have very different holiday traditions, and lately it’s begun to cause some trouble.

She goes to her family and I go to mine, even though we don’t celebrate Christmas.

A few weeks ago she asked me to buy her family presents this year so she could bring it to them.

She says that other people have no problem doing this, but still he resists.

She said her sister’s new bf who’s Jewish will send presents to their whole family even though he doesn’t celebrate either.

I say that’s great for him but unfair to place that expectation on me.

Now she’s really mad at him and points out his hypocrisy.

She says that’s not the point and accuses me of being a cheapskate since I receive Christmas presents from her whole family every year.

I say it’s their choice and while I appreciate the presents, it’s not right to force me to practice a tradition I don’t believe in.

AITA?

You can’t take and take and take without ever giving anything in return.

What did Reddit think?

If this man can’t give gifts, he definitely shouldn’t be getting them in return.

Screenshot 2025 12 10 at 7.12.11 PM Boyfriend Always Received Christmas Gifts For His Girlfriend’s Family, But Refused To Buy Them Any Because He Doesnt Celebrate The Holiday

Maybe this guy really is a cheapskate.

Screenshot 2025 12 10 at 7.12.51 PM Boyfriend Always Received Christmas Gifts For His Girlfriend’s Family, But Refused To Buy Them Any Because He Doesnt Celebrate The Holiday

A greeting card should be the bare minimum here.

Screenshot 2025 12 10 at 7.13.24 PM Boyfriend Always Received Christmas Gifts For His Girlfriend’s Family, But Refused To Buy Them Any Because He Doesnt Celebrate The Holiday

If he doesn’t start stepping up, his girlfriend may just find someone who will.

Screenshot 2025 12 10 at 7.36.31 PM Boyfriend Always Received Christmas Gifts For His Girlfriend’s Family, But Refused To Buy Them Any Because He Doesnt Celebrate The Holiday

He may have framed it as a moral stance, but it sounded a lot more like convenience.

Relationships never work well when one side gets all the perks.

If you liked that post, check out this story about a guy who was forced to sleep on the couch at his wife’s family’s house, so he went to a hotel instead.