June 19, 2025 at 11:15 pm

Former Major Retailer Manager Catches Employees Committing Fraud, But Then Upper Management Decides To Fire Everyone Right Before Black Friday

by Chelsea Mize

shopping cart full of cardboard boxes

Reddit/Unsplash

Hasn’t everyone heard a Black Friday horror story?

But in this tale, the horror is coming from inside the house. Er, from inside the big box store, I guess.

It all started with a manager who was concerned about customers complaining about fraudulent credit card purchases.

A little digging revealed the problem, but the solution caused an even bigger problem!

Let’s see what the deal is…

Tales From a Former LP: As if Black Friday could get any worse.

Hey everyone. With the Retail Holiday from Hell approaching, I wanted to re-tell a tale of the worst Black Friday I’ve gone through.

Hopefully put a little perspective on how much worse things could be for you.

We’re traveling back in time a few years.

It was the good ol’ year of 2007.

Barry Bonds broke the HR record and was then indicted for steroid use.

The iPhone was unveiled.

The last Harry Potter book was released in stores.

Oh and some sort of mortgage crisis. But you know, mostly a good year.

There was a problem, and she was the person for the job.

I was working at a major electronic retailer, as an LP agent. Mostly standing at the front of the store, watching the cameras, checking receipts. Not the best LP job I had but far from the worst.

It was late October when my Manager pulled me into the back office.

Store Manager (SM) was concerned. Corporate was being flooded with calls from people complaining about fraudulent credit card purchases.

He needed me to investigate. I would get additional hours to work in the office and he needed it done ASAP. Holidays were coming up, sales to be made, yada yada.

It all had to do with magazines.

Well, I wasn’t to happy about the extra hours, but I like a challenge.

I started looking at the complaints and the transactions associated with them. Turns out the complaints were all the same.

See a few months previous, around July, the company was pushing magazine subscriptions at the register. You’d come up with your “gold plated” $200 HDMI cables or one of those new hifalutin GPS systems everyone was raving about, and during the checkout, you’d receive an offer for 3 free months of a magazine, or magazines, of your choice.

The store was pushing these hard.

There were even prizes.

At the end of every pay period, the associate with the most sign ups would get at $25 gift card to the store. If the same associate won 3 weeks in a row, they’d earn a pizza party.

Of course, being a crappy retail environment, it wasn’t enough that they push these magazines.

They HAD to sell these subscriptions! It was vital to the future of the company! Any good loyal employee would be able to sell these easily!

And oh yea if you don’t sell enough your hours would get docked.

Back to the problem, there was a connection between the fraudulent charges and the magazine subscriptions.

After all, holidays were coming up, which meant many new hires. If you were getting docked hours, there was a good chance one of the newer associates would take your position come January and you’d be screwed.

Of course none of this was ever said out loud, but we all knew the game.

Well, each and every one of these fraudulent charges revolved around magazine subscriptions. People saying they said no, and then were charged 3 months later for magazines even though they never received anything.

And the biggest issue was as the months went by, more and more people had complaints.

Complaints box is overflowing, how’s OP gonna stymie the deluge?

Through some long investigating we noticed several key things.

1.) One associate was responsible for the first month. She was the weekly winner and won 3 pizza parties in a row.

2.) Eventually, every other front end associate started doing it as well. One week they’d have 10 subs, the next, they’d have 50-60. Each.

3.) The Front End Managers were ecstatic. They were the #1 store in the country for Subs. Our store was killing it! How could this be a bad thing.

It all starts with one person.

Well, as you have all probably guessed, the first “Golden Associate” was signing people up for magazines without their permission to inflate her numbers.

Eventually, she let some people in on what she was doing, and they started as well.

Even the new hires for the holidays started doing it.

If you can’t beat ’em, join ’em… then sign ’em up for a magazine subscription.

We started monitoring the Front End with cameras, and caught several employees on camera doing it.

On top of that, the Corporate Retail discovered one of the geniuses was just sending the magazines to her house.

We used that as leverage to get her to talk. We had all the proof we need for Corporate.

This is almost done I swear.

This is a bold decision.

It’s a Monday.

Next week is Black Friday.

I get pulled into the office again with the entire management team.

SM tells me that Corporate has reviewed what I gathered, along with Corporate LP. The entire Front End staff is getting fired. Today.

Whoa talk about a mass exodus!

Only one associate wasn’t involved with this scam, some new kid who started about 2 weeks ago. Everyone else was getting fired immediately, in order to avoid lawsuits.

The entire management team is aghast.

Black Friday is 10 days away.

Those are a lotta associate shoes to fill.

The Front End management starts protesting until SM tells them that they are partially at fault for not paying attention. If our associates were that successful, they should have found out why and been using it to teach other stores.

Instead they sit all day in there eating and only come out when called. SM doesn’t want to hear any protests from anyone. They are going to work out call in all the Front End associates immediately, and fire them.

They will work doubles this weekend, 1 regular shift and 1 shift strictly for hiring.

OH and instead of 10 hour shifts for everyone Black Friday, the entire store must work 16 hours. 8 in their department, 8 in register.

Anyone who refuses will be fired.

Tough luck. How’s everybody gonna respond to the crackdown?

It’s dead silent in there.

SM thanks me for my work and asks me to stay late to help escort people out. I’m kinda stuck there anyways so I might as well. Every cashier we have is called in and fired.

Word gets out and some of them don’t come in, until they are threatened with police involvement. There are tears, curses, one person being physically restrained. It wasn’t pretty.

The management is scrambling to hire people and train them with less than a week of training.

Now, the Front End manager and I didn’t get along to begin with. Long story but basically she was lazy and terrible at her job. After all this, I was Public Enemy #1 in her book.

I smell a showdown coming…

It all came to a head the Tuesday before Black Friday.

She comes up and hands me a schedule. It has me on Register from 3am-3pm, and then my previously scheduled LP shift of 3pm to midnight.

I laughed and crumpled it up and threw it out.

Gotta be illegal, right?

She goes on a tear. I’m called in SM’s office again and she’s raving about how I’m not a team player and I should be fired for refusing.

Me: LP isn’t allowed to handle money except for investigations. It would be against Corporate Regulations for me to work as a cashier. And we wouldn’t want to upset Corporate at this critical time would we?

Insert the world’s biggest smug grin.

I’ve never seen someone look like they would blow a vein in anger but this woman was 3 steps away from becoming the Red Hulk.

Vindicating for OP, for sure.

Needless to say, Black Friday was the biggest fiasco you’d ever seen.

Untrained employees on registers making mistakes. Old employees leaving after their shift in their department and skipping the shifts on the registers. Lines circling the store and taking an hour plus to get to the cashiers themselves.

Management running around like the sky is falling. It was glorious to watch in a way. Some men just want to watch the world burn I guess.

Especially when those men make minimum wage.

What’s that saying about Nero fiddling?

Let’s check out the comments on Reddit for this one.

One person says, epic tale!

Screenshot 2025 05 23 at 2.05.18 PM Former Major Retailer Manager Catches Employees Committing Fraud, But Then Upper Management Decides To Fire Everyone Right Before Black Friday

Another poster says yeah retailers: such pushers!

Screenshot 2025 05 23 at 2.05.30 PM Former Major Retailer Manager Catches Employees Committing Fraud, But Then Upper Management Decides To Fire Everyone Right Before Black Friday

This person has sympathy for the devil…

Screenshot 2025 05 23 at 2.05.44 PM Former Major Retailer Manager Catches Employees Committing Fraud, But Then Upper Management Decides To Fire Everyone Right Before Black Friday

One poster offers a hearty congrats…

Screenshot 2025 05 23 at 2.05.58 PM Former Major Retailer Manager Catches Employees Committing Fraud, But Then Upper Management Decides To Fire Everyone Right Before Black Friday

And another is just like, OMG!

Screenshot 2025 05 23 at 2.05.07 PM Former Major Retailer Manager Catches Employees Committing Fraud, But Then Upper Management Decides To Fire Everyone Right Before Black Friday

Minimum wage, maximum revenge.

If you liked that story, check out this post about a group of employees who got together and why working from home was a good financial decision.