July 17, 2025 at 2:22 am

Two Expectant Mothers Picked The Same Sentimental Middle Name For Their Child, And Their Friendship Faced Unexpected Tension

by Benjamin Cottrell

pregnant woman holding her belly

Pexels/Reddit

Choosing baby names can bring out all kinds of emotions, especially when family names are involved.

So when two friends ended up choosing the same middle name for their child, things got awkward fast.

You’ll want to read on for this one.

AITA for using a family name for my baby’s middle name, even though it’s the same as a friend’s baby’s middle name?

I recently shared with a friend my fiancé and I’s dream name for the baby we’re expecting, and it contains family names from both of our families.

Little did she know, this was about to unleash a flood of drama.

She later texted me to ask if I was really using our planned middle name because it was the same as the middle name she had picked out for her baby.

The middle name we both had picked is extremely common and happens to be a family name for both my friend and me.

She didn’t see the problem with sharing a middle name, but her friend feels differently.

My fiancé and I don’t see any issue with our kids having the same middle name—maybe a first name, but not a middle name—especially since the name holds meaning to both of us.

She was upset over it, and after I was hesitant to give up my family name, she passively aggressively said she’d change her baby’s name so they’re not the same.

She’s left feeling incredibly conflicted and sad.

I can kind of see where she’s coming from because I know she’s upset that we’re pregnant at the same time and said she just wants her own middle name.

But it breaks my heart to think about not being able to honor my specific family members with that name since it’s been my dream since before I was pregnant, or being blamed for her “having” to change her baby’s name.

AITA?

Expecting a baby is stressful enough without all the unnecessary conflict.

What did Reddit have to say?

It really isn’t that deep.

Screenshot 2025 06 10 at 10.59.18 AM Two Expectant Mothers Picked The Same Sentimental Middle Name For Their Child, And Their Friendship Faced Unexpected Tension

As if it isn’t incredibly common to have the same middle name as someone.

Screenshot 2025 06 10 at 11.00.12 AM Two Expectant Mothers Picked The Same Sentimental Middle Name For Their Child, And Their Friendship Faced Unexpected Tension

Middle names aren’t near as important as first names.

Screenshot 2025 06 10 at 11.01.16 AM Two Expectant Mothers Picked The Same Sentimental Middle Name For Their Child, And Their Friendship Faced Unexpected Tension

It seems like this is about more than just a name for this friend.

Screenshot 2025 06 10 at 11.00.45 AM Two Expectant Mothers Picked The Same Sentimental Middle Name For Their Child, And Their Friendship Faced Unexpected Tension

She never expected a name to create such a rift, especially one that held so much meaning for her.

At the end of the day, she has every right to honor her family, no matter what her friend thinks.

If you liked that story, read this one about grandparents who set up a college fund for their grandkid because his parents won’t, but then his parents want to use the money to cover sibling’s medical expenses.