October 19, 2025 at 9:20 pm

Couple Argues About Whether Or Not To Let The Mother-In-Law In The Birthing Room, And The Midwife Takes The Wife’s Side

by Jayne Elliott

woman holding newborn baby in the hospital

Shutterstock/Reddit

If you were giving birth to your first child, would you want your mother-in-law to be in the room with you when the baby is born?

In today’s story, one woman is in labor when she finds out her mother-in-law wants to be in the room when she gives birth.

She is not okay with this at all!

Let’s see how the midwife handles the situation.

AITA for not letting the MIL into the birth suite?

I’m a new midwife, and last week I had a young couple come in, they looked to be in their early 20s and in active labor.

The woman (L) still had hours to go, and she looked visibly stressed, so I spent a lot of time comforting her and taking her through everything.

She was really sweet to me, even through contractions.

Thank goodness L had this midwife to help her because her partner was no help at all!

Her partner (C), on the other hand, was rude and he kept snapping at me.

He wasn’t giving L any support or encouragement and he was just sitting in a chair on his phone.

Usually, I try to give people the benefit of the doubt because having a baby is intense and a life-changing experience.

Then the mother-in-law showed up.

Later on, when L was in the hardest part of labor, I was told that her MIL had arrived at the hospital and was insisting on being present for the birth.

I went into the room and asked L and C if they wanted her in the room.

L refused but C wanted to.

They started arguing and L was clearly upset and I overheard that she said she hadn’t even known the MIL was coming and had always planned for it to just be her and him in the room.

There was quite a lot of drama about whether or not to let the MIL in the room.

C said he knew MIL was coming and assumed L would be fine with it because the baby was “just as much (MIL’s) as it is ours.”

By that time, L was crying (all of this btw happening while she was 6-8cm dilated so in severe pain), and I was trying to comfort her and C kept insisting she was being ridiculous.

I wasn’t sure what to do because I’ve never been in a situation like this yet.

The midwife ended up taking the mother’s side.

I ended up not letting the MIL in because I figured that L was the one giving birth and that the MIL could still see the baby after the birth.

After the birth, MIL and C yelled at me for meddling into their family business and C accused me of manipulating L into not wanting the MIL in the room. AITA?

She did the right thing. L was the one giving birth. It’s her decision.

Let’s see how Reddit reacted to this story.

Here’s the perspective of another midwife.

Screenshot 2025 09 02 at 4.12.54 PM Couple Argues About Whether Or Not To Let The Mother In Law In The Birthing Room, And The Midwife Takes The Wifes Side

The mother is the patient, so her opinion is what matters.

Screenshot 2025 09 02 at 4.13.11 PM Couple Argues About Whether Or Not To Let The Mother In Law In The Birthing Room, And The Midwife Takes The Wifes Side

Here’s a similar comment.

Screenshot 2025 09 02 at 4.13.34 PM Couple Argues About Whether Or Not To Let The Mother In Law In The Birthing Room, And The Midwife Takes The Wifes Side

She could’ve kicked the dad out.

Screenshot 2025 09 02 at 4.14.07 PM Couple Argues About Whether Or Not To Let The Mother In Law In The Birthing Room, And The Midwife Takes The Wifes Side

This is a good suggestion so she’s better prepared next time a situation like this arises.

Screenshot 2025 09 02 at 4.14.29 PM Couple Argues About Whether Or Not To Let The Mother In Law In The Birthing Room, And The Midwife Takes The Wifes Side

Only one person’s wishes matter when it comes to childbirth.

If you enjoyed that story, read this one about a mom who was forced to bring her three kids with her to apply for government benefits, but ended up getting the job of her dreams.