November 20, 2026 at 5:35 am

A Dad’s Babysitting Favor For His Brother Blew Up Over A Strange Hypothetical Question

by Chris Allen

kids playing on a trampoline

Canva

Hosting relatives should not require putting your own child in second place.

This father agreed to watch his brother’s children for several days.

Then his brother added an unexpected condition.

Every child would be cared for, but one priority became controversial.

Let’s see whether his answer was unfair.

AITA for making my kid a priority over my brothers kids

My brother asked my wife and I to watch his two kids for a couple of days while they were on a small vacation, and we agreed a few months ago.

They’re great, and it’s really fun to have them around.

But then his brother said something that threw everything off.

But my brother mentioned that he expects my wife and I to have his kids at a higher priority than our own daughter because they’re guests.

I told him that they would be loved and cared for, but ultimately our daughter would be our main concern.

Apparently this was the wrong answer.

He said that was wrong and got upset, saying that if the roles were reversed, he would make our daughter a higher priority because it’s what we would expect — which I told him was wrong, and that I wouldn’t expect that.

This father thinks it’s not quite that black and white.

I’m not mistreating his kids, and I’m also not acting like my daughter can do no wrong. She’s definitely had to go sit in the corner a few times.

But at this point, I can’t tell. AITA?

This was supposed to be a favor, not a fight.

What did Reddit think?

This conversation really wasn’t productive in any way.

Screenshot 2025 10 10 at 11.41.49 AM A Dad’s Babysitting Favor For His Brother Blew Up Over A Strange Hypothetical Question

Maybe this conversation was always going to end poorly.

Screenshot 2025 10 10 at 11.42.34 AM A Dad’s Babysitting Favor For His Brother Blew Up Over A Strange Hypothetical Question

This commenter seems to think this dad could have chosen his words a bit more carefully.

Screenshot 2025 10 10 at 11.43.15 AM A Dad’s Babysitting Favor For His Brother Blew Up Over A Strange Hypothetical Question

Perhaps it would have been best to not engage with his brother at all about this.

Screenshot 2025 10 10 at 11.43.48 AM A Dad’s Babysitting Favor For His Brother Blew Up Over A Strange Hypothetical Question

This father promised loving care without pretending his own daughter suddenly mattered less.

His brother’s demand created a competition where none needed to exist.

Enjoyed this story?

Readers who liked this also read this story about an adult child who feels like their family is asking them to donate to a fundraiser beyond their means.
Read Story→