Shutterstock

Birthdays can feel surprisingly heavy when you grew up watching everyone else celebrate milestones you never really got to have.

One college student finally plans something meaningful for her 21st, but when her niece’s party lands on the same day, would you sacrifice it again?

Now, a date change leaves her choosing between another family obligation and the first birthday celebration that has ever truly felt like hers.

See why a baby’s 1st birthday party created a milestone-sized family conflict.

AITA for not going to my niece’s first birthday after originally saying I would?

I (20F) come from an African household where family is everything.

Growing up, I never had a birthday party because it was considered “too expensive,” and I’ve never really received gifts from my family, aside from the occasional one from a friend or my boyfriend.

So, birthdays have always been a bit sore for me.

My niece’s birthday is on September 21st, and mine is on the 27th. When my sister told me she wanted to throw a party for my niece’s first birthday, I was obviously happy to attend.

The sister had reasons for waiting an extra week for the party.

I go to uni in Plymouth, and my family is in London, so I booked time off work to travel up for the weekend of the 21st, assuming the party would be held then.

But now my sister has booked a hall for the 27th, my birthday.

She said she couldn’t do the party the weekend of my niece’s actual birthday because she didn’t want her friends to have to travel with their kids on a Sunday, and she refuses to do it on Saturday (the 20th) because “you can’t celebrate a birthday before it’s happened.”

So now she’s settled on my birthday weekend instead.

Sadly, she already has plans on that date.

I wanted to spend the day with my boyfriend. I already booked time off for that weekend, and so did he. We were planning something lowkey but meaningful, especially since this year is my 21st and my first proper milestone birthday that I’ll be able to celebrate.

My sister says I already agreed to come (which I did, before I knew the date had changed). She even said I could bring my friends, but none of my London friends will be around; they’ll all be back at uni, too. And my uni friends from Plymouth obviously can’t travel five hours and miss uni just to come to a kid’s party full of strangers.

I love my niece, and I do want to celebrate her, but I’ve never been able to do so properly, and now, the one time I thought I could, I might be stuck alone again.

AITA?

Yikes! It’s easy to see both sides, but plans do change.

Let’s see what the fine folks over at Reddit think about this.

This reader suggests she celebrate her own birthday.

Here’s a sentiment many people will agree with.

As this person mentions, the niece won’t remember.

Never Miss a Story

Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.

If you enjoyed this post, check out this story about a teenager whose family thinks she’s selfish for wanting to help plan her own sweet 16.

Excellent advice from this reader.

She originally agreed to attend when the party was expected near her niece’s actual birthday, not on her own 21st.

Once the date shifted, she already had meaningful plans with her boyfriend and no realistic way to merge the celebrations.

Rather than treating her original yes as permanent, her sister could have acknowledged that changing the date also changed the agreement.

Celebrating a niece is important, but turning 21 only happens once too.

Add TwistedSifter to your Google News Add us as a preferred source on Google

Author

Chris Allen