July 16, 2025 at 2:22 am

Couple Is Struggling To Make A Plan To Buy A House, But One Short Conversation Has Put The Whole Thing In Jeopardy

by Ben Auxier

exterior of the front of a house

Pixabay/Reddit

You may have heard tale of an ancient ritual once known as “buying a home.”

Archeologists and anthropologists are unsure exactly what elements went into this practice, though there is general agreement that it centered around something called “having money.”

In our story today, some young scientists attempt to recreate this ritual by various means, and have some trouble at that.

AITA for telling my husband’s brother about a private conversation my husband had with his dad?

Context: me (24f) and my husband (26m) are trying to buy a house. Because of the economy, most of the money is coming from his grandma’s inheritance.

She left behind a house, which my husband’s dad is selling, to then split the money between my husband and his 2 siblings, which is what she wanted, but was not written in the will.

The house we are buying is (fake numbers) around 150k, with 100k of the money coming from my husband’s grandma’s inheritance.

The inheritance won’t cover the price of the house.

I am contributing 15k, and we are both saving to cover the costs of renovations.

Because we both live in an HCOL area, we don’t really have any other money to put into it, but we are trying to save as much as possible.

We are wanting to move to a much lower COL area so once we live there we will be saving even more money.

We asked our parents for loans for the remaining amount, because we can pay them off within about 5 years.

Here’s how the parents reacted to the idea of loaning them money.

My husband’s pitch to his dad for the loan only included the repayment that my husband can do, not my contribution, because his dad doesn’t want to me to be involved (for misogynistic reasons in my opinion).

Even though I am contributing to the house payment as well, only my husband’s name will be on the title because I am not yet a citizen of the country we are buying in, but he is.

He initially had a conversation with his dad, who said no to giving us the loan (I want to point out that he VERY well off), because he wanted it to be a ‘learning experience’.

I also asked my parents, who basically said they would, but only if their LLC owned a percentage of the house.

We aren’t sure if we are going to agree to this.

Then they mentioned the situation to her husband’s brother.

The problem comes in, that a few days ago, my husband’s brother (20m) popped round to pick something up while my husband was out of town.

We had a legit 3 minute conversation, where he asked about the move.

I told him that we were trying to buy the house and asked his dad for a loan but he said no.

That was literally the whole conversation.

Turned out, that short conversation was a mistake.

After that, husband’s brother went to see his dad and mentioned what I told him.

Husband’s dad then berated my husband, and said that I should not have spoken to husband’s brother about something that was a private conversation between the two of them.

He also threatened to no longer give my husband the inheritance money.

Well that sounds kinda drastic…

In my opinion, his dad is in the wrong.

Yes, the conversation was just between the two of them, but I am involved in this house, and we are buying it together. Also, I didn’t badmouth his dad at all, I just said we asked for a loan and he said no.

My husband is now really mad at me for messing with family dynamics, and is really worried that he won’t get the inheritance anymore.

In hindsight, I shouldn’t have told his brother about it, but I don’t think I said anything bad. I think it boils down to his dad not seeing me as a person involved in buying the house, and thinking that it is just between the two of them.

So, AITA?

It was a mistake to bring up the loan, but she didn’t realize that until it was too late.

Check out what the comments on Reddit had to say:

2025 06 23 18 25 09 Couple Is Struggling To Make A Plan To Buy A House, But One Short Conversation Has Put The Whole Thing In Jeopardy

Doesn’t seem like a lot of likable people in this story.

2025 06 23 18 25 18 Couple Is Struggling To Make A Plan To Buy A House, But One Short Conversation Has Put The Whole Thing In Jeopardy

Are there no prisons? Are there no workhouses?

2025 06 23 18 25 43 Couple Is Struggling To Make A Plan To Buy A House, But One Short Conversation Has Put The Whole Thing In Jeopardy

But a strong word of warning:

2025 06 23 18 24 54 Couple Is Struggling To Make A Plan To Buy A House, But One Short Conversation Has Put The Whole Thing In Jeopardy

That’s certainly advice worth heeding.

If you thought that was an interesting story, check this one out about a man who created a points system for his inheritance, and a family friend ends up getting almost all of it.