October 27, 2025 at 11:35 pm

Man Refused To Let His Roommate’s Daughter’s Friend Move In After Learning About Her Past, But Now He’s Being Accused Of Judging Too Harshly

by Heather Hall

Man being firm in his decision to not help a young girl

Pexels/Reddit

Sometimes saying yes can come at a cost you can’t afford to pay.

Imagine working for years to rebuild your life after a felony conviction, finally finding peace, only to be asked to let an unstable stranger move into your home.

Would you take the risk to help them out?

Or would you protect what you’ve built, even if it means being called heartless?

In the following story, one man finds himself facing this very decision and opts for the latter.

Here’s what happened.

AITA for refusing to let my roommate’s daughter’s friend move in, partly because I fear the risk of losing everything I have rebuilt?

My wife and I rent part of our home out to a roommate, and we’ve worked hard to have a good, quiet house.

My roommate’s daughter asked if her friend could stay because of family problems. At first, I was willing to talk about it, but then I got to thinking.

This girl already got kicked out of her mom’s house, then moved in with her dad and grandma, and they kicked her out, too.

She turned her nose up at the idea when it was first offered to her.

From what I hear, it’s because she’s never home and doesn’t want to follow rules.

When RM1 (my roommate’s daughter) told her what was offered here, she kind of turned her nose up at it, like it wasn’t good enough. I don’t get that.

You either need a place or you do. Don’t look a gift horse in the mouth, you know.

But here’s the big thing. I got a felony record for robbery. It was literally just a text message, and it still tore my life apart.

I spent years rebuilding. I finally got some peace, and I’m not about to risk all that.

Now, he’s decided it’s risky, and he’s not interested in helping at all.

I don’t know this girl. She’s young and unstable and has been bouncing house to house. I’m not saying she would make up something about me, but it’s possible. I’ve seen it happen to other people.

If she ever got mad and said something false, it didn’t matter if it was true or not. I could get arrested right out of my house in front of neighbors, end up on the mugshot sites, and lose everything I built—all for being nice.

So, I told my roommate no, I wasn’t comfortable with it. She understood, but some people say I’m being too cautious or judging.

But I ain’t risking my life for somebody I don’t know just cause they need a place to stay. I feel bad for her, but I gotta protect what I got.

AITA?

Wow! Sounds like he has a good reason.

Let’s see what the folks over at Reddit think about his situation.

According to this person, the other people who are judging him can help.

Roommate 3 Man Refused To Let His Roommate’s Daughter’s Friend Move In After Learning About Her Past, But Now He’s Being Accused Of Judging Too Harshly

Here’s some solid advice.

Roommate 2 Man Refused To Let His Roommate’s Daughter’s Friend Move In After Learning About Her Past, But Now He’s Being Accused Of Judging Too Harshly

For this reader, it’s okay to refuse.

Roommate 1 Man Refused To Let His Roommate’s Daughter’s Friend Move In After Learning About Her Past, But Now He’s Being Accused Of Judging Too Harshly

As this person explains, he’s worked too hard to lose what he has.

Roommate Man Refused To Let His Roommate’s Daughter’s Friend Move In After Learning About Her Past, But Now He’s Being Accused Of Judging Too Harshly

He needs to stand firm.

He’s not wrong for not wanting to get involved. It seems like she has family and other options for help.

If you liked that post, check this one about a guy who got revenge on his condo by making his own Christmas light rules.