November 19, 2025 at 5:21 pm

College Student Was Asked To Buy A Couch As His Share In The Entire Apartment, But He Refused And Offered To Split It Three-Ways Instead

by Heide Lazaro

An empty living space with a door and a small table

Pexels/Reddit

Living with roommates requires compromise and communication.

This man lives with two other roommates in college.

His roommates demanded that he buy a couch by himself to “even things out.”

But he thought it was unfair and instead tried to compromise.

But his offer to split the cost wasn’t good enough, and now they say he’s being disrespectful.

Check out the full story below for all the details.

AITA My roommates want me to buy a couch myself

We are three college kids living in San Diego.

My two other roommates want me to solely buy the couch for our apartment.

The reason they want me to buy a couch is because they are saying I didn’t bring anything communal to the apartment when we moved in.

This man is rarely in the apartment and doesn’t use his roommate’s stuff.

For context, one roommate brought a small table with two chairs, some dishes, a coffee table, and a rug.

The other roommate brought the TV and the stand for the TV.

I am rarely in the apartment as I work and study all day.

I leave at 8 a.m. and don’t get back until 12 or 1 a.m.

I don’t ever use their stuff in the apartment and don’t watch TV.

He offered to split the cost of the couch three ways, but they didn’t agree.

The problem that I am having is that they didn’t ask me to buy the couch.

They are basically telling me that I have to buy the couch.

They say I am not being a considerate roommate.

I am willing to compromise.

I offered to split it three ways, but they are refusing to do so.

Now, they’re calling him disrespectful.

They are saying I have been disrespectful to both of them over the past month.

Because I’ve been delaying and non-communicative about buying the couch.

Am I in the wrong?

Let’s see how others reacted to this story.

This user shares their personal thoughts.

Screenshot 2025 10 27 at 8.47.29 PM College Student Was Asked To Buy A Couch As His Share In The Entire Apartment, But He Refused And Offered To Split It Three Ways Instead

This person agrees with not buying a new couch.

Screenshot 2025 10 27 at 8.48.11 PM College Student Was Asked To Buy A Couch As His Share In The Entire Apartment, But He Refused And Offered To Split It Three Ways Instead

Here’s a similar thought from this one.

Screenshot 2025 10 27 at 8.52.12 PM College Student Was Asked To Buy A Couch As His Share In The Entire Apartment, But He Refused And Offered To Split It Three Ways Instead

I can totally see their point, says this user.

Screenshot 2025 10 27 at 8.52.44 PM College Student Was Asked To Buy A Couch As His Share In The Entire Apartment, But He Refused And Offered To Split It Three Ways Instead

Finally, this works fine, too.

Screenshot 2025 10 27 at 8.53.51 PM College Student Was Asked To Buy A Couch As His Share In The Entire Apartment, But He Refused And Offered To Split It Three Ways Instead

Compromise is important when you’re sharing space with other people.

If you liked that post, check this one about a guy who got revenge on his condo by making his own Christmas light rules.