February 16, 2026 at 8:35 am

Employee Found Out A Coworker Was Lying On His Time Card And Getting A Lot Of Overtime Pay, So He’s Considering Reporting Him

by Matthew Gilligan

man at a desk

Shutterstock/Reddit

To tattle, or not to tattle, that is the big question

And sometimes we all have to ask ourselves if we should spill the beans on a scheming co-worker or keep the bad news to ourselves.

The story below involves a worker who knows that one of his fellow employees is cheating the system and they’re conflicted about what to do next.

Let’s take a look!

WIBTA if I reported my coworker for falsifying his time card?

“This afternoon, I happened to sit at my computer and my coworker left his punch in-out login open.

Uh oh…

I saw that he showed to have clocked out at 2 PM, even though I know for a fact that he left at 10:30 this morning.

It also showed that he clocked in at 6 AM, despite the fact that I arrived at 7 AM and he didn’t arrive until about 7:45.

If you’re wondering how he managed this, despite not physically being present at work, our system can be accessed by basically anything with an internet connection, so yes it’s possible to clock in and out on your phone.

This was shady stuff!

I then got curious and I snooped through his time card. Not cool, but whatever. Every single day he punched in an hour before me, despite arriving 30-45 minutes late every single day.

I knew he took some liberties and rode the clock here and there, but I didn’t know it was this extreme. He also runs personal errands multiple times per week, all of which he stays on the clock for. It’s always the same; dry cleaning, haircut, whatever.

Wow…

All things that can be done after business hours. I looked a little deeper, and this guy has been regularly stealing about 40 hours of overtime every 2 weeks. This has been going on for 2 years now.

Now here is where I’m torn. I’ve worked with the guy for nearly 3 years, so I’ve come to know him well. We get along great and we work well together.

He’s also recently divorced, so I know he needs the extra money for child support and legal fees, etc.

I want to say I believe what he’s doing is unethical, and I do, but I also know I have to pull his weight so much when he’s not around, and his checks are nearly double mine because of what he’s doing.

I believe that he’s actually screwing me out of money, especially when he leaves for several hours at a time to “pick up his dry cleaning”.

AITA for wanting to report him?”

Reddit users spoke up.

This person said they’re NTA.

Screenshot 2026 01 20 at 8.40.22 AM Employee Found Out A Coworker Was Lying On His Time Card And Getting A Lot Of Overtime Pay, So Hes Considering Reporting Him

Another reader agreed.

Screenshot 2026 01 20 at 8.40.31 AM Employee Found Out A Coworker Was Lying On His Time Card And Getting A Lot Of Overtime Pay, So Hes Considering Reporting Him

This individual had a lot to say.

Screenshot 2026 01 20 at 8.40.43 AM Employee Found Out A Coworker Was Lying On His Time Card And Getting A Lot Of Overtime Pay, So Hes Considering Reporting Him

Another Reddit user shared their thoughts.

Screenshot 2026 01 20 at 8.40.57 AM Employee Found Out A Coworker Was Lying On His Time Card And Getting A Lot Of Overtime Pay, So Hes Considering Reporting Him

And this individual weighed in.

Screenshot 2026 01 20 at 8.41.07 AM Employee Found Out A Coworker Was Lying On His Time Card And Getting A Lot Of Overtime Pay, So Hes Considering Reporting Him

This worker is dealing with a big dilemma…

If you liked that post, check out this one about an employee that got revenge on HR when they refused to reimburse his travel.