September 10, 2026 at 3:10 pm

She Chose to Babysit the Neighbor’s Kids Over Seeing Him — He Accused Her of Not Caring About Their Relationship

by Chris Allen

couple arguing outside sitting on ground with coffee cups

Shutterstock

Healthy couples can survive one evening apart, right? That’s in the rule book I think.

This woman accepted a small babysitting job for her neighbor.

Her boyfriend treated the decision like a personal betrayal.

Things escalated fast.

See where everything went wrong.

AITAH for accepting a babysitting job instead of spending time with my BF?

My (20F) boyfriend (21M) has a full-time job, and we spend about 1.5-2 hours per evening together on weekdays before he has to go back to his house.

We also spend all of Friday evening and the weekend together. This has been going on for a few months now.

For context, we have been together over 3 years.

So one day, she had someone else vying for her time.

My neighbor asked me to babysit her kids for an evening in the near future. It will take up my entire evening, and my boyfriend and I won’t be able to see each other that day.

I didn’t think this was a big deal since it’s just one day.

She sees this more as a favor than a real job.

For context, my neighbor is probably going to pay me less than minimum wage, but we haven’t even discussed prices yet. In the past she has paid well below minimum wage.

I also see accepting this job as doing my neighbor a favor, so I’m happy to settle for a small payment.

But her boyfriend wasn’t understanding at all.

I told my boyfriend that I accepted this job so he knew it was coming up in my schedule. He got so angry with me and said that I think being paid “next to nothing” is worth more than spending time with him, and that I’m inconsiderate of him for accepting the job.

He said the relationship was one-sided because of this.

This clearly points to larger problems in their relationship.

He also claims that every time I say I miss him it’s bull because I clearly don’t miss him if I’d rather take this job over spending 1.5-2 hours with him on one evening.

He also said “if that’s the case, screw you” and just left my house all mad because I accepted this job.

So she fights back against his unfair expectations.

I told him he was being unreasonable and that it’s one evening out of all the time we spend together. He says he’s owed a major apology from me, and that if I truly cared about spending time with him I wouldn’t have accepted this job.

I didn’t think I did anything wrong by accepting this job. It’s one night, and it’s not like we can’t call or text while the kids are asleep.

So, AITAH?

Sounds like this relationship may be headed for some trouble.

What did Reddit have to say?

This commenter points out that her boyfriend doesn’t seem to have her best interests at heart.

Screenshot 2026 03 30 at 3.56.20 PM She Chose to Babysit the Neighbors Kids Over Seeing Him — He Accused Her of Not Caring About Their Relationship

Maybe she really should be getting paid more for the babysitting.

Screenshot 2026 03 30 at 3.57.04 PM She Chose to Babysit the Neighbors Kids Over Seeing Him — He Accused Her of Not Caring About Their Relationship

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a group trip that sours when additional guests are added without agreement.

She shouldn’t need her boyfriend’s permission to spend her evening another way.

Screenshot 2026 03 30 at 3.57.39 PM She Chose to Babysit the Neighbors Kids Over Seeing Him — He Accused Her of Not Caring About Their Relationship

Despite spending nearly every evening and weekend together, her boyfriend exploded over one missed night.

He demanded a major apology and claimed her babysitting decision proved their relationship was one-sided.

Sir, it’s one evening, not a breakup documentary.

Enjoyed this story?

Readers who liked this also read this story about a sister who refuses to give up her own holiday traditions to spend the day with her family at her brother’s cabin.
Read Story