An HOA President Puts Her Foot Down Over A Law The Condo Manager Has Long Ignored At Tenants’ Request, Bringing Years Of Flexibility To An End
by Chris Allen

Shutterstock
HOA rules feel different when the person demanding them must face every unhappy resident.
This board president ordered the building’s heat turned on every October 1.
Management warned that warm weather could make apartments unbearable.
She insisted anyway.
Let’s see what happened when temperatures rose.
HOA President wanted heat!
I manage a condo complex in New York City.
It has central A/C that, once switched to winter mode, can’t go back to cooling until spring.
NYC law requires heat starting October 1st, but October swings from chilly to unseasonably warm, so we usually wait for a real cold stretch before turning it on.
The tenants have been fine with this for years, since one chilly day was better than being unbearably hot for ten.
But then, things started to change.
Last year, the board president lost it over a slightly chilly day towards the middle of October.
She sent an email demanding we turn on the heating system immediately and stating that going forward, the heat must always be on by October 1st.
She said didn’t care if other units would be uncomfortably warm, that she is the board president, and she should be comfortable in her unit.
Yikes! Read on to find out what happened when the condo manager replied.
This year, we followed her orders: on October 1st the heat went on.
At the annual meeting, the tenants were furious. They wanted to know why a system that had worked for years was suddenly “broken.”
The president started chewing me out, forgetting her email the previous year.
But this condo manager wasn’t about to take the complaint lying down.
Not wanting to deal with her nonsense, I got the green light from my boss to pull up her own email on the projector. Her exact words, her exact demands.
She went pale and, for the first time ever, had nothing to say.
She lost her position in the election. Her replacement was very happy we called her out, and we renewed our contract for five more years.
There’s a clear lesson here.
All things turn out right in the end, and when you behave like the HOA president in this story did, you can be sure you’ll get what’s coming to you sooner or later.
She was entitled enough to demand her comfort above all others – and she got exactly what she wanted. But it came at a cost.

Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
Let’s see how folks on Reddit responded to this situation.
This person thought that the design of the heating system truly sucked for everyone involved.

While others agreed that there were definite upgrades needed.

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about a woman who escalates her issue to the state when a third family is added to a shared neighborhood well.
And this Redditor was concerned that the company could be held liable, now the flaw had been pointed out.

The manager followed the president’s order, and residents arrived at the annual meeting furious about overheated apartments.
When she blamed management, her own demanding email appeared on the projector before everyone.
Enjoyed this story?
Author
Chris Allen
Categories: Life & Drama, Neighbors & Community
Tags: · bad leadership, democracy, dictatorship, heat, heating system, hoa, HOA president, hvac, malicious compliance, nyc, NYC law, picture, reddit, remake, stories, top, work

Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.



