October 8, 2024 at 3:49 am

Brother Rudely Demands Sibling Leave The Living Room So He Can Be Alone, But Sibling Claims They Were There First

by Benjamin Cottrell

Source: Getty/JackF, Reddit/AITA

Living with family means all bets are off when it comes to personal space.

When this siblings-turned-roommates duo enters a standoff over who lays claim to the living room, a battle of wills ensues.

Read on for the full story!

AITA for “confronting” my brother’s crap?

Today, I was laying on the couch in our fairly large living room, while reading a book.

My brother came from his room with a pen and a notebook, sat down at the opposite side of the living room, set down his stuff, then asked me to leave.

Confused, the other sibling started asking questions.

I said, “Why? You barely see me and I’m not making a sound. This is the living room.”

He did not respond.

When they refused to budge, the brother asks again.

A few moments later, he said, “So, why haven’t you left yet? Are you trying to be annoying or something? Just want to understand your thought process here.”

At that point, I was annoyed, so I decided to come up with a reply of similar structure, to make it clear that I think he’s being a jerk.

It’s their turn to ask the questions.

So I replied, “So, why do you randomly decide that a third of the apartment has to be emptied of my presence, with what little effect it has on you? Are you trying to be annoying or something? Just want to understand your thought process here.”

The brother continued their passive aggressiveness.

He then said, “Just go to one of the other two thirds of the apartment, is it that hard?”

So, I ignored him.

He got up a minute or two later and said “Hope you’re happy,” and left the room.

The other sibling explains their relationship up to this point.

Now I would like to clear up that my brother and I are not exactly “good friends,” but we’re not enemies either.

He often asks me to leave him alone, say if I were in his room, or if he was studying, and I do grant these requests.

They still don’t find it fair he was making these kinds of requests over their common spaces.

However, I felt that this time it’s not really justified.

I literally had to peek out of the couch I was laying on to see him, and made absolutely no noise whatsoever.

Am I the AH?

No one knows stubbornness better than two siblings dueling it out.

What did Reddit think?

This user agrees it’s not right of him to try to claim the living room.

Source: Reddit/AITA

Logically, the brother doesn’t have much of a leg to stand on.

Source: Reddit/AITA

If alone time is what he wants, the living room isn’t the right place.

Source: Reddit/AITA

This redditor suspects the brother’s bad mood has little to do with his sibling.

Source: Reddit/AITA

Living room = fair game. Sorry, bro.

These two siblings may live close together, but emotionally they’re miles apart.

If you thought that was an interesting story, check this one out about a man who created a points system for his inheritance, and a family friend ends up getting almost all of it.