March 20, 2025 at 1:22 pm

Girlfriend Wanted Hypothetical Solidarity From Her Traumatized Boyfriend, And His Hesitation Turned A What-If Into A Real Argument

by Chelsea Mize

bald woman deep in thought

Unsplash/Reddit

Cancer sucks, we all know that.

But in this story, a mere hypothetical cancer causes real relationship drama.

A girlfriend was hoping her boyfriend would want to be a united front, but when he hesitated due to childhood trauma, she wasn’t happy.

This is a hairy one…

AITA for not shaving my hair?

I 27m and my wife 25f have been together for over 8 years.

We have always agreed on everything but yesterday we got into an argument.

Her family has been struggling with cancer and she is scared that she will get cancer as well.

This is completely valid but we’ve been talking about it a lot.

This is a big ask.

One day she came to me and asked: “If I got cancer would you shave your hair?”

I was stunned when she asked this because I have always been extremely caring with my hair. When I was little, my dad would shave my hair off as a punishment and I’d get bullied for it.

She knows this very well. She has always seen me taking hours in the bathroom just because I was caring for my hair and has complimented me on it a lot.

This is a nice gesture.

But now she has been seeing a lot of heartwarming content of people shaving their hair for their family members that have cancer.

I see why she would want me to do it, but as I said I have actual shaving trauma and when she asked me about it I just broke down.

She said I was a wuss and if I had cancer she would shave off her hair for me.

AITA?

Solidarity is important, but is this a hair too far?

Let’s check the comments on Reddit.

This person says, sentiment over performance.

Screenshot 2025 03 04 at 5.16.57 PM Girlfriend Wanted Hypothetical Solidarity From Her Traumatized Boyfriend, And His Hesitation Turned A What If Into A Real Argument

Another commenter says, no need to relive that trauma.

Screenshot 2025 03 04 at 5.22.31 PM Girlfriend Wanted Hypothetical Solidarity From Her Traumatized Boyfriend, And His Hesitation Turned A What If Into A Real Argument

Another person in the no-trauma column…

Screenshot 2025 03 04 at 5.20.27 PM Girlfriend Wanted Hypothetical Solidarity From Her Traumatized Boyfriend, And His Hesitation Turned A What If Into A Real Argument

Here’s another NTA who says they’d never ask someone to do this.

Screenshot 2025 03 04 at 5.18.24 PM Girlfriend Wanted Hypothetical Solidarity From Her Traumatized Boyfriend, And His Hesitation Turned A What If Into A Real Argument

Another person says the asker is the AH.

Screenshot 2025 03 04 at 5.17.52 PM Girlfriend Wanted Hypothetical Solidarity From Her Traumatized Boyfriend, And His Hesitation Turned A What If Into A Real Argument

This hypothetical situation is hair raising.

If you liked that post, check out this story about a guy who was forced to sleep on the couch at his wife’s family’s house, so he went to a hotel instead.