June 30, 2025 at 9:23 am

She Compared Every Guy She Dated To Her Best Friend, So He Started Wondering If The Unfair Comparisons Were Hurting Them Both

by Benjamin Cottrell

man talking with his female friend in the kitchen

Pexels/Reddit

When you’re friends with an ex, it can open the door for all sorts of potential complications.

His ex-girlfriend-turned best friend repeatedly claims they’re better as friends, yet always finds herself drawn to guys who supposedly remind her of him. But when she goes on to badmouth those same guys, he starts to feel more offended than flattered.

Read on for the full story!

WIBTA if I 32(M) told my bestfriend 32(F) to stop telling me she’s dating guy’s that are just like me?

My best friend keeps telling me she’s dating guys that are just like me.

The two have a bit of a history.

For a little background, we’ve been friends since 2010 and dated briefly back in high school.

However, she has told me she doesn’t want to date again—from fear of losing me as her friend if we broke up.

Fair, I can respect that.

But he’s began to notice a troubling pattern.

However, every time she gets in a new relationship, she says the guy is just like me.

Long story short, they end up not being like me at all. They cheat on her and end up treating her like garbage.

So, WIBTA if I ask her to please stop saying this with every guy she dates?

It would pretty hard not to take that personally.

What did Reddit have to say?

Maybe certain types of conversations should just be off the table for them.

Screenshot 2025 05 28 at 4.25.19 PM She Compared Every Guy She Dated To Her Best Friend, So He Started Wondering If The Unfair Comparisons Were Hurting Them Both

Perhaps this halfway friends, halfway dating dynamic isn’t serving them any longer.

Screenshot 2025 05 28 at 4.25.58 PM She Compared Every Guy She Dated To Her Best Friend, So He Started Wondering If The Unfair Comparisons Were Hurting Them Both

Maybe a good ol’ heart-to-heart could help clear things up.

Screenshot 2025 05 28 at 4.28.01 PM She Compared Every Guy She Dated To Her Best Friend, So He Started Wondering If The Unfair Comparisons Were Hurting Them Both

Is some sort of conflicted energy getting in the way of a true friendship between them?

Screenshot 2025 05 28 at 4.28.38 PM She Compared Every Guy She Dated To Her Best Friend, So He Started Wondering If The Unfair Comparisons Were Hurting Them Both

Once upon a time, the comparison was once flattering, but now it’s more insulting than anything.

If she truly values their friendship, she’ll understand why he wants her to stop.

If you thought that was an interesting story, check this one out about a man who created a points system for his inheritance, and a family friend ends up getting almost all of it.