August 18, 2025 at 5:55 pm

Taking A Lunch Break Is Mandatory, But The New Manager Makes It More Complicated Than It Needs To Be

by Jayne Elliott

man wearing headphones and eating a salad at work

Shutterstock/Reddit

Some jobs are really flexible where you can basically take a lunch break whenever you want and not have to worry about being interrupted. Other jobs don’t operate like that, and it’s possible to have to stop in the middle of your lunch break and go back to work.

In today’s story, one employee found a workaround for the hassle of clocking in and out for lunch, but their new manager didn’t like this workaround.

Let’s see how the story plays out.

New Manager Forces Me To Take Lunches, So I do.

So the place I work at had mandatory lunch hours we’re supposed to take between certain hours based on what hours we’re working.

I’m an operator, so it’s not like I can just walk away from the job if somethings going on. My duty is to keep the plant running, and make sure nothing bad is happening to the equipment.

So, after constantly having to call the old manager about missing my clock ins or clock outs because I got busy with something, he told me about this survey I could fill out whenever this happened that basically said “I took my lunch, I just didn’t clock out for it” and payroll would adjust it accordingly.

Here’s how that would work.

So, on that note, if you’re on an official clocked out lunch as an operator, and an alarm goes off or you’re interrupted for any reason, you have to clock back in and address the issue, and then either clock out again and retake your entire lunch, or just call a manager/fill out the survey and you’re basically paid for your lunch.

So, I filled out the survey every single morning, choosing to just skip the whole ordeal of trying to remember my lunches. That’s literally what the survey is for.

Now, onto the MC.

The new manager doesn’t like that OP is filling out a survey instead of clocking out.

New manager comes in, a month in he pulls me aside and says I haven’t been clocking out for lunches.

I inform him of the survey.

He tells me that’s only for the occasional missed lunch.

I disagree with him, the writing clearly states “I voluntarily choose to skip my meal”.

He basically orders me to start clocking out for lunch.

He’ll comply, but he’s going to time it just right!

Sneaky MC ensues.

So for the next two weeks, since I have a two hour window to take a half hour lunch I waited until about the last half hour and then specifically wait until I see a certain piece of equipment drawing close to a nuisance alarm level, and then clock out for lunch.

Somewhere between 5-10 minutes later the alarm goes off.

This creates a new problem.

Oops, guess I have to clock back in, and go silence that alarm.

Oh no! Not enough time left to restart my lunch!

I did that for two weeks straight, forcing the company to pay me for my half hour interrupted lunches.

New manager tried to ignore it. Until HIS boss (who was like..old old manager, but got promoted a few years back) comes down to ask me why I stopped filling out the survey.

He explained that situation.

I inform him of New Managers instructions, to which he rolls his eyes and tells me to go back to using the survey. Never heard another word about it.

And the cherry on top?

We just got all new time clocks a few weeks ago.

The survey lingo pops up when we clock out now, instead of just a name and a time. . So I STILL don’t have to clock out for lunch. Now I just click ‘Ok’, agreeing that I took my lunch at some point, and I’m good to go. *fist pump*

It’s too bad taking a lunch break is such an ordeal, but it sounds like the new time clock makes it easier than ever.

Let’s see how Reddit reacted to this story.

Seriously, this doesn’t sound like a win.

Screenshot 2025 07 25 at 11.36.11 PM Taking A Lunch Break Is Mandatory, But The New Manager Makes It More Complicated Than It Needs To Be

There are two scenarios, and neither one is a win.

Screenshot 2025 07 25 at 11.36.33 PM Taking A Lunch Break Is Mandatory, But The New Manager Makes It More Complicated Than It Needs To Be

Another person thinks the company is the only one who is winning.

Screenshot 2025 07 25 at 11.37.01 PM Taking A Lunch Break Is Mandatory, But The New Manager Makes It More Complicated Than It Needs To Be

OP should be paid for an interrupted lunch.

Screenshot 2025 07 25 at 11.37.19 PM Taking A Lunch Break Is Mandatory, But The New Manager Makes It More Complicated Than It Needs To Be

OP must not work in California.

Screenshot 2025 07 25 at 11.37.45 PM Taking A Lunch Break Is Mandatory, But The New Manager Makes It More Complicated Than It Needs To Be

Getting paid less to work more is never a win.

If you liked that post, check out this post about a rude customer who got exactly what they wanted in their pizza.