November 30, 2025 at 11:15 pm

A Customer Was Told He Couldn’t Get A New Bank Card Because Of An ATM Mishap, So He Closed His Account And Immediately Opened A New One There To Get His Card

by Matthew Gilligan

man with a bank teller

Shutterstock/Reddit

Folks, we see a lot of stories from Reddit’s “Malicious Compliance” page, but I’m gonna go on the record and say that this one is a dandy!

I don’t want to spoil anything, so go ahead and check it out for yourself!

You Cannot Have Another Bank Card.

“I was in a co-op program at my University.

The national bank on campus (a somewhat isolated campus due to the agriculture programs it offered) also had branches in the city near to where I was doing my co-op work terms.

This was long ago when ATMs were newish.

I withdrew some money with my bank card in the evening. Then the next day, I wanted to get more, so I used the ATM at lunch.

Doh!

Instead of getting cash, the machine ate (retained) my card and ended the transaction. I went into the branch to see what could be done.

Me: the ATM just took my card

Teller: I’m sorry sir (that was nice, I was pretty young), do you know your account number?

Me: yes I do! (I had a cheque book with me). Here it is.

TELLER TYPES AND LOOKS SAY THE SCREEN.

Huh?

Teller: I’m sorry, sir, you exceeded the withdrawal limit of your account.

Me: Uhh, forty dollars yesterday, and today is too much?

Teller: Yes, sir

Me: Can I have my card back?

Teller: No, sir. Your account can no longer be linked to a card because of the limit violation (I’m an ATM criminal!).

Me: But I don’t have an overdraft. I’m not even close. You can see the balance, right?

Teller: I’m sorry, sir, but that is the bank’s policy.

Me: I’d like speak to a manager (I know, jerk move, but it’s my money)

TELLER TAKES ME TO A MANAGER

Manager: The Teller tells me you had a bit of trouble with our ATM

Me: That’s right, I’d like a new card for my account

Wow…

Manager: I’m sorry, the bank’s policy is not to trust people that don’t follow the rules. We cannot issue you a new card EVER AGAIN.

Me: It’s still my money, right?

Manager: Of course, sir!

Me: I want to close my account

Manager: Here, let’s go have Teller take care of that for you.

TELLER GOES THROUGH ALL THE WORK TO CLOSE MY ACCOUNT AND GIVE ME CASH.

He had an idea…

Me: Thank you very much. Now I understand that new accounts get a bank card, is that right?

Teller: Yes, sir, you get a card and PIN as soon as you open an account. You even get some table cheques to start you off while your order is being printed

Me: I’d like to open an account and get a bank card for it, please

I complied with their rules, and ended up with exactly what I started with. Alas, the poor teller was the one that had to do all the work, but no way was I going to pay out of system fees to use their ATMs on campus if I’d gone to a different bank.”

Here’s what people had to say on Reddit.

This reader shared their thoughts.

Screenshot 2025 11 14 at 8.28.27 AM A Customer Was Told He Couldnt Get A New Bank Card Because Of An ATM Mishap, So He Closed His Account And Immediately Opened A New One There To Get His Card

Another individual weighed in.

Screenshot 2025 11 14 at 8.28.35 AM A Customer Was Told He Couldnt Get A New Bank Card Because Of An ATM Mishap, So He Closed His Account And Immediately Opened A New One There To Get His Card

This person spoke up.

Screenshot 2025 11 14 at 8.28.54 AM A Customer Was Told He Couldnt Get A New Bank Card Because Of An ATM Mishap, So He Closed His Account And Immediately Opened A New One There To Get His Card

That was a pretty clever move!

If you liked this post, you might want to read this story about a teacher who taught the school’s administration a lesson after they made a sick kid take a final exam.