November 18, 2025 at 6:21 am

Roommate Steals Other Roommate’s Drinks And Scissors, So The Landlord Gives Him An Eviction Notice

by Jayne Elliott

two angry male roommates sitting back to back

Shutterstock/Reddit

Imagine moving into your first apartment with a roommate. It would be important to set some boundaries and respect each other’s boundaries.

If your roommate didn’t respect your boundaries and then lied about it, would you let it go or get the landlord involved?

In this story, one man is in this situation, and he chooses the second option. Let’s read all the details.

AITA for asking/demanding my roommate to replace the drinks he had taken without my permission. Which led him to getting evicted?

So I (22M) have been living with my roommate (34M) for a few months. We didn’t know each other before moving in together. He was already living there when I moved in.

I’ve only ever lived with cousins or friends, so I was nervous and wanted to set boundaries early

I told him I don’t like sharing groceries (except cleaning supplies) but that if he ever used or took something, he should at least let me know, though ideally not use my stuff at all.

He agreed and shared his own boundaries, which I’ve respected

This would be annoying.

The next day, I bought a 6-pack of alcoholic drinks in case my friends came over.

A week later, only 2 were left.

I asked my roommate if he drank them, and he claimed I must’ve gotten drunk and forgotten.

I only drink socially and never to the point of blacking out, so that wasn’t true. I told him I wasn’t mad about the drinks, just about being lied to, but he doubled down

Scissors don’t just walk off by themselves.

I let it go to avoid conflict but told our landlord (who lives upstairs) just to keep him informed, and I explicitly said I didn’t want him to take any action since I wanted to keep the peace

A few days later, my kitchen scissors went missing.

Since the last time I confronted him didn’t go well, I decided not to this time and just compromised by using scissors from my sewing kit until I could buy new ones.

But then those also went missing. So I finally asked him if he’d seen them, and he said no again

So his roommate is the one with the drinking problem!

At that point, I was frustrated and told the landlord again, reminding him about the drinks.

He said he’d talk to my roommate.

The next day, my roommate admitted to taking the drinks, blamed his drinking problem, and apologized. He insisted he’d replace them plus extras.

I told him he didn’t have to, just not to do it again.

He still insisted, so I agreed

The roommate seemed to think he’d forget.

Two months went by with no replacement.

I’ve been short on money lately, and my friend’s birthday party is coming up where we each bring something. So I asked him if he could finally buy me that one pack he promised.

If he said no, I’d have dropped it. But instead, he said he thought I’d let it go and called me a petty little b-word

The landlord got involved.

That’s when I stopped asking and demanded he replace what he took.

He stole from me, lied about it, promised to make it right, didn’t follow through, and still insulted me for bringing it up.

Our landlord heard the argument and came downstairs. I explained what happened, and it ended with my roommate getting an eviction notice

Since then, I’ve kept my food and kitchen stuff locked in my room with a mini fridge I bought after he first stole my drinks until he moves out, just in case

That thief sounds like a horrible roommate, and it’s not just about what he took. It’s that he lied about it.

It’d be hard to live with someone you can’t trust.

Let’s see how Reddit reacted to this story.

The landlord was probably waiting for an opportunity to evict him.

Screenshot 2025 10 15 at 9.14.19 AM Roommate Steals Other Roommates Drinks And Scissors, So The Landlord Gives Him An Eviction Notice

This person must really like sewing.

Screenshot 2025 10 15 at 9.14.38 AM Roommate Steals Other Roommates Drinks And Scissors, So The Landlord Gives Him An Eviction Notice

If anything, he should’ve taken action sooner.

Screenshot 2025 10 15 at 9.14.55 AM Roommate Steals Other Roommates Drinks And Scissors, So The Landlord Gives Him An Eviction Notice

This person wishes him luck with his next roommate.

Screenshot 2025 10 15 at 9.15.11 AM Roommate Steals Other Roommates Drinks And Scissors, So The Landlord Gives Him An Eviction Notice

Who knows what he would steal next!

Screenshot 2025 10 15 at 9.19.09 AM Roommate Steals Other Roommates Drinks And Scissors, So The Landlord Gives Him An Eviction Notice

You shouldn’t have to worry about your belongings getting stolen in your own home.

Screenshot 2025 10 15 at 9.19.47 AM Roommate Steals Other Roommates Drinks And Scissors, So The Landlord Gives Him An Eviction Notice

Nobody wants to live with a roommate they can’t trust.

If you enjoyed that story, read this one about a mom who was forced to bring her three kids with her to apply for government benefits, but ended up getting the job of her dreams.