January 4, 2026 at 3:35 am

Crazy Customer Refuses To Believe Anything A Supervisor Says, And Wants To Speak To The Store Manager… But She’s Actually Talking To The Store Manager

by Jayne Elliott

woman in green shirt, black vest and glasses working at a grocery store

Shutterstock/Reddit

Retail workers often have to deal with crazy customer situations, but imagine dealing with three crazy situaitons in just one day!

In this story, one store manager is in that exact situation, and one of the crazy situations involves a customer who refuses to believe anything she says.

Let’s read all about it.

“You’re a supervisor. You aren’t a manager, honey. There’s a difference.”

I am a manager for a general store in the Midwest. Typically, this is a small town, so we get a lot of regulars, no one causes too much of a fuss. But for whatever reason, all the crazies came out yesterday.

It started when I opened the store and a man entered without a shirt on. We do have a no shirt, no shoes, no service policy, so I informed him he had to leave and come back with one on.

Shirtless Guy: “Am I offending you?”

Me: “It isn’t a personal decision. It is company policy. I’m sorry.”

Was this a hypothetical situation or was he being serious?

SG: “Suppose I don’t have a shirt.”

Me: “Then I can’t allow you to shop here.”

SG: “Then I guess I won’t.”

He then hiked up his pants and strutted out the door as if our store wasn’t good enough for him, anyway.

There were a couple more crazy situations.

Then, as I was stocking, I overhear two girls chatting, when one of them mumbles and says “… like hers!” and points at me. Then they kept walking. I hope it was something flattering. I didn’t want to investigate.

Near the end of the day, I’m called to dairy because “a customer is requesting to speak to a manager.” Words I live for. So I put on my happy face and asked what the situation was.

Old Lady: “He’s [dairy associate] telling me you don’t have anymore Halloween cookies.”

Me: “That’s right. We had them discounted until the end of the week. Now we have Christmas cookie dough.”

When it’s sold out, it’s sold out.

Old Lady: “It’s too early for Christmas. Certainly everyone didn’t buy ALL of the Halloween cookies. Do you have any more pumpkin or ghost cookies in the back?”

Dairy: “I checked in the back already.”

Old Lady: “I’m speaking with the manager, honey.”

Whoa!

The customer refused to believe her.

Me: “If [dairy associate] said we’re out of them, we’re out of them. It’s his department and he knows the product we have in stock. Besides, they are deleted items at this point and we wouldn’t be able to sell them if we had them.”

Old Lady: “Well I don’t get it. Where did they go?”

Me: “We either sold out or the rest went back to the manufacturer for disposal.”

Old Lady: “DISPOSAL? Well I wanted to buy them! Why would they throw them out like that? Let me see your back room. I don’t believe they’re gone.”

That customer had some nerve!

Me: “We don’t allow customers-”

Old Lady: “I know you have them!!”

At this point, she walks past me into the back. Not in the cooler, though, just where the offices are. She’s looking all around, confused.

Old Lady: “Where is it?”

Me: “Ma’am, I’m going to have to ask you to leave.”

The lady still doesn’t believe her.

Old Lady: “You don’t have the authority! Where is the STORE manager?”

Me: “I am the STORE manager. You’ve been disrespectful to me and my employees, please leave.”

Old Lady: “You’re a supervisor. You aren’t a manager, honey. There’s a difference.”

Eventually, the lady gave up.

We are literally standing in front of my office that says “Store Manager” on it as she makes that comment.

I try to tell her this, but she keeps cutting me off demanding I take her to the dairy cooler or find the cookies myself.

The third time she calls me honey I walk into my office and shut the door. I tell myself “If she starts pounding on the door, I’m calling the police.”

Thankfully she let out a huge “UGH!” and I heard her stomp off, cursing under her breath.

So it was an exciting day to say the least.

Wow! Three crazy situations in one day. That’s a lot!

Let’s see how Reddit reacted to this story.

This would’ve been a good comeback!

Screenshot 2025 12 14 at 10.15.32 PM Crazy Customer Refuses To Believe Anything A Supervisor Says, And Wants To Speak To The Store Manager... But Shes Actually Talking To The Store Manager

Here’s a suggestion for the cookie lady.

Screenshot 2025 12 14 at 10.15.55 PM Crazy Customer Refuses To Believe Anything A Supervisor Says, And Wants To Speak To The Store Manager... But Shes Actually Talking To The Store Manager

The cookie lady really wasn’t making sense.

Screenshot 2025 12 14 at 10.16.09 PM Crazy Customer Refuses To Believe Anything A Supervisor Says, And Wants To Speak To The Store Manager... But Shes Actually Talking To The Store Manager

Another person had a similar cookie experience.

Screenshot 2025 12 14 at 10.16.23 PM Crazy Customer Refuses To Believe Anything A Supervisor Says, And Wants To Speak To The Store Manager... But Shes Actually Talking To The Store Manager

Retail workers have to deal with some pretty crazy customers!

If you liked this post, check out this story about an employee who got revenge on a co-worker who kept grading their work suspiciously low.