January 9, 2026 at 8:55 pm

Woman Brings Some Leftover Soup Home From Her Job, But She Gets Mad At Her Boyfriend When He Assumes She Didn’t Want Her Little Sister To Eat It

by Jayne Elliott

teenage girl eating chicken soup in bed

Shutterstock/Reddit

If you worked in a food service job and got to bring leftover food home, would you be upset if someone in your family ate the leftovers?

In this story, one woman is in that situation, and she’s picky about who she is okay with eating the leftovers.

Her boyfriend didn’t know she was okay with her little sister eating the food, and that’s where the drama begins!

Let’s read the whole story.

AITA for getting mad at my bf for questioning my sister eating my food?

I (19f) am in college and work part time.

My bf was staying over at my house because we had a free long weekend, but on Saturday night my work asked me to come in for a few hours to fill in for someone who called out sick as we had a huge rush for some corporate jobs event or wtv for those hours and I felt guilty leaving my super nice manager alone to deal with it so I went to help.

I went in around 6 and came home around 10:30.

She’s picky about who in her family can eat the food she brings home.

The place I work at makes soup and bread bowls and sometimes I take some home and I label it because I don’t want my mom’s fiance to eat it however, I do not care if my little sister (15f) eats it.

I have told my bf before I got annoyed when my mom’s fiance ate it, but have never mentioned my sister but he knows we are pretty close.

While I was at work my little sister decided to heat some up, and my bf who was in the kitchen at the same time questioned her about it.

Really wierd context but my sister and my bf were in the same ASL 1 class my sister’s freshman year/his senior year, however from my knowledge they never really spoke.

Her boyfriend confronted her sister about the food.

My sister was apparently just having a really bad day and was in a lot of pain (medical condition + period + long day) just not a good combo, and she signed to him that it hurt to talk and that I let her have it.

They went back and forth with my bf saying that I might need/want some and saying things such as it wasn’t hers to take and it ended with my sister finally speaking up and telling him to ask me.

When he did he told me that she sounded really off and that was his sign to stop badgering her.

And I asked why he would do it in the first place.

He was just trying to help.

He said he wanted to make sure I didnt get my food taken.

I said that even if that was true why would I care that my suffering little sister had some of my freaking soup. I then said she literally had to sign to you and you didn’t take that as a hint.

He told me that he was just being protective of my food.

Now, everyone is upset.

And I told him wrong place wrong time.

And he has clearly been upset about it since and my sister is upset at him because she said she really didn’t want to talk to anyone right then.

And now I’m conflicted and it feels like I’m stuck between a rock and 3 hard places.

I understand everyone’s perspective here. Basically, the boyfriend should’ve stayed out of it, but at this point, OP needs to realize that he meant well. Let’s all forgive and forget, and he’ll know for next time.

Redditers had mixed opinions on this situation.

This person defends the boyfriend.

Screenshot 2025 11 14 at 10.55.03 AM Woman Brings Some Leftover Soup Home From Her Job, But She Gets Mad At Her Boyfriend When He Assumes She Didnt Want Her Little Sister To Eat It

But this person thinks the boyfriend should’ve stayed out of it.

Screenshot 2025 11 14 at 10.55.36 AM Woman Brings Some Leftover Soup Home From Her Job, But She Gets Mad At Her Boyfriend When He Assumes She Didnt Want Her Little Sister To Eat It

Another person thinks both boyfriend and girlfriend messed up.

Screenshot 2025 11 14 at 10.55.56 AM Woman Brings Some Leftover Soup Home From Her Job, But She Gets Mad At Her Boyfriend When He Assumes She Didnt Want Her Little Sister To Eat It

And this person can’t reach a conclusion.

Screenshot 2025 11 14 at 10.56.14 AM Woman Brings Some Leftover Soup Home From Her Job, But She Gets Mad At Her Boyfriend When He Assumes She Didnt Want Her Little Sister To Eat It

That’s a lot of drama over a bowl of soup.

If you liked that post, check out this story about a guy who was forced to sleep on the couch at his wife’s family’s house, so he went to a hotel instead.