August 29, 2025 at 4:23 pm

His Girlfriend Moved In With Him And He Asked Her To Help Pay The Bills, But She Doesn’t Think She Should Have To Pay Anything For The First Year

by Jayne Elliott

unhappy couple arguing

Shutterstock/Reddit

Imagine having your own place and then your girlfriend moves in with you. Do you let her live there rent free, or do you expect her to help pay the bills?

In today’s story, one man asks his girlfriend to help him pay the bills, but she has excuses for why she thinks that’s unreasonable.

Let’s read the whole story.

AITA for asking my girlfriend to contribute to bills after she moved in without us planning it?

I (28M) recently ended a four-year relationship that left me emotionally drained.

Early in our relationship, I discovered my girlfriend was still communicating with past partners, sometimes flirting and denying our relationship.

She explained that her family believes in maintaining connections with exes, which made me uncomfortable, but I chose to stay.

Their living situation has changed several times.

We lived with her parents for a time while I was getting back on my feet. They provided support but also exerted control and judgment.

Eventually, I secured my own place, and we agreed she would stay with her family. However, she began staying over and gradually moved in without a clear discussion.

After several months, I asked her to contribute to household expenses.

She responded that she hadn’t planned to pay anything for the first year and that her parents supported this stance, citing the time I lived with them rent-free.

There have been other big issues in their relationship.

Complicating matters, she had previously created a profile on a sugar daddy site during an argument, claiming it was to provoke me. She also attempted to reintroduce an ex into our lives under the guise of helping a friend, which felt like a breach of trust.

Following our breakup, she sent a message expressing love but also accusing me of emotional and physical harm, stating she forgave me but needed to cut contact permanently.

Now, I’m left questioning my actions.

Was I wrong to ask her to contribute financially? Should I have addressed these issues differently

She sounds toxic. Maybe kicking her out is the better course of action.

Let’s see how Reddit reacted to this story.

This person suggests eviction.

Screenshot 2025 07 09 at 8.32.03 PM His Girlfriend Moved In With Him And He Asked Her To Help Pay The Bills, But She Doesnt Think She Should Have To Pay Anything For The First Year

Another person urges him to move on.

Screenshot 2025 07 09 at 8.32.27 PM His Girlfriend Moved In With Him And He Asked Her To Help Pay The Bills, But She Doesnt Think She Should Have To Pay Anything For The First Year

Pulling her family into this was ridiculous.

Screenshot 2025 07 09 at 8.32.48 PM His Girlfriend Moved In With Him And He Asked Her To Help Pay The Bills, But She Doesnt Think She Should Have To Pay Anything For The First Year

She has a lot of red flags.

Screenshot 2025 07 09 at 8.33.20 PM His Girlfriend Moved In With Him And He Asked Her To Help Pay The Bills, But She Doesnt Think She Should Have To Pay Anything For The First Year

Hopefully he ends this relationship.

If you thought that was an interesting story, check out what happened when a family gave their in-laws a free place to stay in exchange for babysitting, but things changed when they don’t hold up their end of the bargain.