December 21, 2025 at 11:55 pm

Woman Has Three Healthy Kids, But Her Sister-In-Law Can’t Have A Baby Naturally. Now The Sister-In-Law Came Up With An Odd Idea That Caused Tension In The Family.

by Heide Lazaro

Mom hugging her sleeping baby

Pexels/Reddit

A quiet, innocent family gathering can quickly turn into a chaotic mess.

This woman has a pretty decent life, and her sister-in-law is jealous of her.

As her SIL couldn’t bear a child naturally, she came up with a strange idea that triggered everyone in the family.

Read the full story below and find out what happened.

Entitled SIL wants custody of my baby

I’m 36F and my SIL is 40F.

I’ve been married to her brother for over 10 years.

And there’s always been some jealousy and resentment from her.

She’s always felt like I had the life she wanted, not necessarily with her brother, but the marriage, family, job stability, etc.

This woman has 3 kids, while her sister-in-law couldn’t have a child naturally.

I have 3 kids: 10F, 8M, and a 3-month-old female.

She got married last year and they decided to start trying for a baby.

Unfortunately, she was told that she can’t have children naturally.

She was understandably devastated. and the family comforted her as best as we could.

During a family dinner, her sister-in-law offered a strange suggestion.

We recently had a family dinner and in the middle of it, she says:

“(My name), I think it’s really unfair that you got to have 3 kids and I can’t have any.

Your baby is my last chance to raise a child.

I think you should give her to me during the week so I can create a motherly bond with her.

And you can have her on weekends.”

The whole family erupted with their own opinions.

Before I could respond, the entire table erupted with everyone talking at once.

I took my older kids upstairs.

When I got back to the dining room, her husband was asking what the hell is wrong with her.

And why she would even think to ask that.

She asked her sister-in-law to leave.

She was trying to justify herself when I asked them to leave.

I also said that she’s no longer welcome at my house or around my children until she gets help.

She started screaming that I don’t deserve my life or my children.

And that I stole her baby from her.

Her mother-in-law and SIL’s husband apologized to her.

Her husband and MIL kept apologizing.

They dragged her out of the house, still crying and screaming.

Now, my kids want to know why their aunt wants to take the baby.

Let’s find out what others have to say about this.

This user shares their personal thoughts.

Screenshot 2025 12 09 at 3.44.10 PM Woman Has Three Healthy Kids, But Her Sister In Law Cant Have A Baby Naturally. Now The Sister In Law Came Up With An Odd Idea That Caused Tension In The Family.

This person gives some sound advice for safety.

Screenshot 2025 12 09 at 3.44.43 PM Woman Has Three Healthy Kids, But Her Sister In Law Cant Have A Baby Naturally. Now The Sister In Law Came Up With An Odd Idea That Caused Tension In The Family.

Here’s a possible response to the kids.

Screenshot 2025 12 09 at 3.45.09 PM Woman Has Three Healthy Kids, But Her Sister In Law Cant Have A Baby Naturally. Now The Sister In Law Came Up With An Odd Idea That Caused Tension In The Family.

Protect your kids and stay safe, advises this one.

Screenshot 2025 12 09 at 3.45.30 PM Woman Has Three Healthy Kids, But Her Sister In Law Cant Have A Baby Naturally. Now The Sister In Law Came Up With An Odd Idea That Caused Tension In The Family.

Finally, people agree that her request is unreasonable.

Screenshot 2025 12 09 at 3.45.56 PM Woman Has Three Healthy Kids, But Her Sister In Law Cant Have A Baby Naturally. Now The Sister In Law Came Up With An Odd Idea That Caused Tension In The Family.

Some people think babies are like stuffed toys that can be borrowed once in a while.

If you liked that story, check out this post about an oblivious CEO who tells a web developer to “act his wage”… and it results in 30% of the workforce being laid off.