No one likes to be judged based on first impressions, even if it’s unavoidable most of the time.

That said, when it’s someone in your own home, you tend to get a little defensive.

This guy laughed when his brother’s new girlfriend asked him an insulting question.

Check out the details to find out whether or not you think she was out of line.

AITA for laughing at my brother’s girlfriend’s psychoanalysis of me?

I [17m] am really into collecting colognes. I have 30+ full sized bottles as well as 50+ smaller sample sized decants (1-3 ml decants).

Some of this admittedly is Christmas/birthday presents from friends and family, but I also buy with my own money, trade bottles I do have for bottles I want, and have a cologne review tiktok page that’s popular enough for some companies to send me free bottles.

So I don’t want to give the impression of being daddy’s money.

When his brother’s new girlfriend saw the bottles, she drew an unsavory comparison.

Anyways, my brother brought his girlfriend over, and I was giving her a tour of the house.

We went to my room, she asked why I had so many cologne bottles, and I essentially said I always enjoy smelling new scents and am never satisfied that I’ve found the best scent when there’s ones out there that I haven’t smelt.

She asked if I was a f-boy, I said I don’t think so, and asked why.

She said based off of how I always felt the need to try out new colognes and could never settle with what I had being enough for me, I probably do the same with women.

He laughed at her assumption, leaving her irritated.

This made me laugh, and I asked if she had taken her first psych class or something.

She got offended and asked me why I was laughing, and I admitted that I just frankly thought that was a really stupid analogy to make and inanimate objects and living humans aren’t the same.

AITA?

This guy was not out of line if you ask me.

Let’s see whether or not Reddit agrees!

This person thinks he should have insulted her back.

He’s just a kid!

They probably just learned something about her.

She can dish it out but she can’t take it.

She told on herself.

Hopefully this was the humble pie she needed.

Even if she didn’t order it.

If you thought that was an interesting story, check out what happened when a family gave their in-laws a free place to stay in exchange for babysitting, but things changed when they don’t hold up their end of the bargain.