November 21, 2026 at 8:20 pm

Letting Her Twins Choose Where To Sit At Lunch After Their Friend Group Splits Puts A Mother At Odds With Her Ex Over Her Refusal To Intervene

by Chris Allen

twin teen girls with hoodies posing

Canva

Twins may share a birthday, but they do not always share the same social life.

In high school, one sister wants independence while the other feels increasingly alone.

A lunch request brought those needs into direct conflict.

Their mother chose not to force an answer.

Let’s see why the family remains divided.

AITA for not making my twin girls sit together at lunch because I find it unfair to one of them

My two girls (twins) are in their freshman year of high school. I will call them Sara and Mia.

During elementary school, they were basically always together. In middle school, Mia started to feel resentment about always being with Sara, so the school tried to split them up as much as possible.

This was hard because the classes were not big. I made it a point to have activities that were just their own.

As they got older, separating them got easier.

Mia got really into sports, and Sara into theater. This seemed to help, and we did more separating.

They got their own birthday parties and not a shared one, for example. Mia really thrived with this, but Sara did not. It has been a lot harder for Sara to be her own person (Mia was always the dominant twin when they were together).

High school was a big change, and for the first time, they were completely separate, with no shared classes. Sara has been having difficulties, and it got worse this past month. The friend group she was hanging out with broke up, and she has been sitting alone at lunch.

Sara asked Mia to sit together with her friend group at lunch, and Mia told her no. This resulted in a big fight between the two.

She made the decision she thought was best.

Mia’s point was that these were her friends, and Sara needed to learn to make her own and basically not piggyback off Mia. Sara’s point was that they were twins, and she is sad sitting alone.

I told Sara very gently that Mia doesn’t have to sit with her at lunch and encouraged her to keep trying to make friends, and basically put herself back out there.

Sara has been crying since, and my ex is giving me an earful. I don’t know if I made the right call on this.

AITA?

Eek! It’s easy to see where she’s coming from, but this is a tough situation.

Let’s see how the readers over at Reddit think this mother should handle it.

According to this comment, the family needs therapy.

Twins 3 Letting Her Twins Choose Where To Sit At Lunch After Their Friend Group Splits Puts A Mother At Odds With Her Ex Over Her Refusal To Intervene

For this reader, Sara needs therapy.

Twins 2 Letting Her Twins Choose Where To Sit At Lunch After Their Friend Group Splits Puts A Mother At Odds With Her Ex Over Her Refusal To Intervene

This person sees no winner here.

Twins 1 Letting Her Twins Choose Where To Sit At Lunch After Their Friend Group Splits Puts A Mother At Odds With Her Ex Over Her Refusal To Intervene

If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about an incoming college student who does not want to share their grandparents’ monetary gift with a medically complex sibling.

Yet another reader who thinks everyone is at fault.

Twins Letting Her Twins Choose Where To Sit At Lunch After Their Friend Group Splits Puts A Mother At Odds With Her Ex Over Her Refusal To Intervene

The mother let Mia keep her independent friend group while encouraging Sara to build new connections.

With one twin lonely and the other tired of being a package deal, nobody’s feelings were unreasonable.

Enjoyed this story?

Readers who liked this also read this story about a bride who invites her groom’s “best woman” out to dinner in order to get to the bottom of her true feelings for her future husband.
Read Story→