A Hotel Employee Turned Away a Guest Who Showed Up on the Wrong Date—and Shut Down Demands for an Instant Full Refund
Magnific/Reddit
Hotel booking mistakes can become expensive when rooms are in high demand.
In this story, a hotel employee dealt with an upset guest who arrived a night early and demanded a refund.
The hotel was completely booked during a major convention, and the guest had prepaid through a third-party booking site.
Because the reservation was non-refundable and the hotel couldn’t accommodate the guest that night, he couldn’t really do anything about it.
How would you deal with this situation? Read the full story below.
Guest booked the wrong night via OTA during a sold-out convention week. Now wants a resale refund
I had a situation last week during a massive convention rush.
It got me curious about how other properties handle this behind the desk.
A guest rolls up late at night, ready to check in.
The house is 100% committed, with every room accounted for.
This front desk employee couldn’t help the stranded guest.
I pull up their details, and sure enough, they booked for tomorrow night instead of tonight.
Classic time zone mix-up while booking on their phone mid-travel.
Naturally, they booked prepaid through a third party.
Since we were completely sold out, I couldn’t just shift the dates and slide them into a room tonight, even if I wanted to.
They were stranded for the night and obviously upset.
The guest wanted to get a full refund of the room.
Then came the refund conversation.
They wanted to cancel tomorrow’s reservation on the spot for a full refund.
But our policy is 24 hours prior to check-in day.
It was already past midnight, with check-in just hours away.
On top of that, it’s an OTA virtual card situation where our hands are tied at the desk anyway.
He told the guest he would have to check with his manager first.
That’s when they dropped the classic logic on me:
“Look, it’s convention week, and the entire city is packed.
You guys are easily going to resell that room tomorrow.
If you sell it, can you just refund us?”
I told them I couldn’t promise anything and that I’d have to check with my manager in the morning.
Now, he’s asking how other hotels deal with the same situation.
Fast forward to the next day.
Not only did we keep their reservation as non-refundable because of the policy.
But we also turned around and resold that exact room for triple the rate, thanks to the convention demand.
So what do you guys actually do here?
Does your property stick to the rules, pocket the non-refundable revenue, and cash in on the resale?
Or would your management have cut them a break once the room sold?
Never Miss a StorySign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
The guest made a booking mistake, and OP was just being honest that he couldn’t do anything about it as per hotel policy.
However, since the hotel later resold the exact room for triple the rate, I think they could reasonably consider a partial refund as an act of kindness.
But, of course, it’s understandable that not everyone would be required to do this.
I guess the moral of the story is to always be careful and double-check when booking hotels using your mobile phone.
Let’s read the responses of other people to this story.
This user shares their personal thoughts.
Here’s another personal remark.
I always book direct, says this one.
People are saying the same thing.
If you enjoyed this story, check out this post about an IT employee who thought a ticket was closed, only to hear otherwise from the client’s manager.
Finally, another one chimes in.
Policies can be strict, but a little flexibility can go a long way.
Enjoyed this story?
Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
