She Introduced Her Lifelong Friend To Her New Neighbor — Then Got Upset When The Neighbor Was Invited To Girls’ Dinner Instead Of Her
Pexels/Reddit
Introducing two people you know is always a tiny social gamble. Best-case scenario, everyone gets along, and you’ve helped create a new friendship. Slightly more complicated scenario: they get along so well that they start making plans without you.
One 28-year-old woman found herself in exactly that awkward territory after her longtime friend Audrey introduced her to a new neighbor, Kayla.
Kayla had recently moved to town for a new job and admitted she was struggling to meet people. Since the woman knew how intimidating it could be to make friends—especially as someone who’s fairly shy herself—she exchanged numbers with Kayla and encouraged her to reach out.
Then came what seemed like the perfect opportunity. Another friend, Hannah, was hosting a girls’ dinner with around 10 people, several of whom didn’t know one another. The woman invited Kayla, figuring it could help her start building a social circle.
There was just one potentially uncomfortable detail: Audrey wasn’t invited.
And when Audrey found out, the woman didn’t exactly tell her the real reason why.
AITA for inviting my friends’s neighbor to an event?
My (28F) friend Audrey (27F) recently introduced me to her new neighbor Kayla (28F) who had recently moved in across the hall.
Audrey and I were catching up when she decided to call over her new neighbor from across the hall, Kayla. We spent the evening chatting and Kayla mentioned she had just moved here for a job starting next month, and doesn’t know any people in the area yet, besides Audrey.
She noted she has been struggling because she finds it difficult to make friends and doesn’t know how to approach the situation in a new town. Kayla and I exchanged phone numbers I told her to reach out for plans on any weekend that she wants to.
How lovely.
Shortly after, about a week later, I got invited to a girl’s dinner party by my long time friend Hannah (26F). Hannah is one of those girls who seems to have a million friends- she is extremely loving a supportive to all of her friends. She continuously invites me to events that she hosts, which I appreciate as I am typically more on the shy side.
I reached out to Kayla and invited her along. I thought this would be a great opportunity to meet some girls from the area. I figured there would be a variety of guests there- approximately ten girls would be attending and we had not all met before. Hannah even included in her agenda for the night to have an introduction for all the people who had not met.
The issue is that I did not invite Audrey. I have known Audrey just about my entire life and I love her like a sister. But she did not make a good impression on Hannah when they first met.
Oh boy.
Audrey is more out there tends to take over the conversation when I am around and made a joke at my expense.
Like I mentioned, Hannah loves all of her friends fiercely. The joke did honestly hurt my feelings, but I brushed it off.
However, Hannah shared she found Audrey to be a bit much and didn’t appreciate how she treated me that night. Since then, I have chosen to keep them separate with plans to ensure there is no awkwardness.
Fair enough.
So now, I have invited my friend’s neighbor to an event but not the friend that introduced us.
Audrey is upset- and to mitigate any reason to tell her that Hannah doesn’t care for her- I told her that I was only able to invite one person and chose Kayla so that she could get to meet some people.
I don’t know if that was the best choice- to invite Kayla at all, or to lie to Audrey to avoid telling her that my friend doesn’t like her. AITA?
Commenters were somewhat divided on the situation, but much of the criticism wasn’t about inviting Kayla. Once Audrey introduced the two women and they exchanged numbers, Kayla became her own person and potential friend—not someone Audrey permanently gets first dibs on socially.
The trickier part was the lie.
Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
It makes sense that the woman didn’t want to tell Audrey, “Hannah doesn’t like you and doesn’t want you at her events.” That would probably create unnecessary drama between two people she’s intentionally kept separate. But saying she was only allowed one guest when that wasn’t true also created a problem that didn’t need to exist. If Audrey ever learns otherwise, the exclusion may feel considerably more personal.
There’s another uncomfortable issue underneath all of this: Audrey apparently made a joke at her friend’s expense that genuinely hurt her feelings, and Hannah noticed it immediately. Keeping Audrey and Hannah apart may avoid awkwardness, but it doesn’t address why Audrey feels comfortable treating her lifelong friend that way.
Inviting Kayla wasn’t necessarily a betrayal. But managing Audrey’s feelings with a made-up explanation may have turned a fairly reasonable decision into a much messier one.
This person says NTA in such a tough sitch.
This person says OP is just being nice and did nothing wrong.
And this person says this is an important part of friendships.
Introducing two friends doesn’t come with lifetime dibs on every invitation they exchange afterward.
Enjoyed this story?
Sign up to get our BEST stories of the week straight to your inbox.
